Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Ob, don't confuse them with stone cold reality, they have ideals to pursue.
 

Haut Medoc

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jun 29, 2004
Messages
10,645
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Didn't Scrooge say, "Are there no poor houses then?"

Then stay at home & cook your own freakin' burger....
If you are too lazy or busy to do it yourself, then ya gotta pay!.......
If a Big Mac goes up a quarter, I ain't gonna sweat it....
If you regularly go to a place that serves $10 burgers, then you have money to burn anyway.....
I'll tell ya what, if any one has disposable income, it is the average American teenager.....
Think about that!
You know the one with 0 deductions...
That's what is gonna finance Social Security.....
That is if'n Dubya will remove his hand from the cookie jar!.........JK
 

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Haut, Let's just suppose for a minute that they do raise the minimum wage $2.00 as proposed. What happens to you as a contractor?

Nothing you say? I'll bet your employees will want that 2 buck raise also. No big deal? Or do you refuse and possibly lose someone that you have time and money invested in training.

So what does that $2.00 raise really cost you? It isn't just 2 bucks. It's also the increase in your contribution for your employees taxes and higher workmans comp.... about another $1.50 to $2.00 per hr.

So of course to off set this you have to raise your prices, which may cost you a project as the "consumer" just can't afford it now.... maybe $10,000.00 profit? How many times in a year can that happen to you before you may have to start laying off employees?

Think it through. A higher minimum wage does not create new money, it just redistributes the money.(Socialism) New jobs created by profitable businesses create money, not just shuffle it around.(Capitalism)
 

Haut Medoc

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jun 29, 2004
Messages
10,645
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

There is no such thing as new money unless the government prints it or borrows it......
If you have legal employees that are willing to work construction for minimum wage where are they?
I would like to place an order for a truckload!
The construction industry will not suffer if the minimum wage is raised.....
An entry level construction job isn't nearly as low as the proposed raise.......
I would like to see some of the wealth redistributed anyway......
Corporate greed & "Golden Parachutes" sicken me.....
Especially the Wall St. types who have made Billions of of simply manipulating money......
But I digress......
Sorry, I can't buy your arguement.......JK
 

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

LOL Haut, I'd love to find legal minimum wage labor myself... ain't gunna happen.

I was referring to your present employees wanting a raise because "everyone else got one".... what would you do?... and how do you think it would affect your business?
 

Haut Medoc

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jun 29, 2004
Messages
10,645
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

I would say that you are lucky to be making as much as you do now & have a cool boss....8).
I don't see it as hurting business at all.....
The biggest threat to my business is people who are hiring illegal immigrants......
It makes it much harder for me to be competitive & pay living wages to U.S. citizens who are in my employ.....JK
 

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

I would say that you are lucky to be making as much as you do now & have a cool boss.....

I think the boss is pretty cool myself... but then, I'm the boss. 8)

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. I can see where the Illegal Aliens would be a bigger threat to you, don't you have an enforcement agency for contractor licenses?
 

Haut Medoc

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jun 29, 2004
Messages
10,645
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

The only ones that care is L&I......
Which is the equivalent of workman's comp.....
As long as they get their $, they don't care....
There are alot of ways to get fake ID, SS #'s & Green cards.....
I just wish the geniuses in Washington could figger out how to seal the border, & come up with a plan for truly verifying an individuals legal status......
This ain't a Bush bash either, I would like to see some action on the other side of the aisle.....
If a wouldbe illegal worker can get in, why not a would be terrorist?
Frankly, I am surprised that there have been no more attacks on U.S. soil........JK
 

woodrat

Ensign
Joined
Jul 27, 2004
Messages
949
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Crunch;

If you already pay $15/hour, then what the heck does the minumum wage going up a few dimes have to do with your situation anyway? Or are you just in the argument because you see it as part of the culture war?

CATO institute? Oh yeah, there's a group with no agenda to promote!

About 8 years ago or so, I was doing some remodelling on a house and found a section of the classified ads from a 1968 newspaper. Here's what I saw:

Since 1968, the basic wage for starting position in the local sawmill had gone up fourfold.

The price of a 2 bedroom home in the mill town had gone up 10 fold.

The price of a 5 year old ford truck had gone up 15 fold.

The newspaper didn't reveal what executive compensation had done in that time. But I can guess that it increased by more than fourfold...

Now what part of this slice of economic data has to do with your culture war and the supposition that people are poor because they are lazy?

Minimum wage exists to keep the most unscrupulous employers from trying to go back to slavery, which some would do if they could get away with it. To the person who noted that he started out working for $.15 more than minimum, what do you think you would have started at had there been no such thing as minimum? Same thing? Or less?
 

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

If you already pay $15/hour, then what the heck does the minumum wage going up a few dimes have to do with your situation anyway?

If you read my post you wouldn't have to ask that would you..... thought not.
 

woodrat

Ensign
Joined
Jul 27, 2004
Messages
949
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

I had posted before I got through the whole thread.

I read your post. It still doesn't make sense. If you have no minimum wage employees, I think that you are just reaching to say that suddenly all of your people are going to want a $2.00 raise because the people on minimum got raised.

$15/hour is pretty good starting wages; I don't see anyone walking away from that unless they've been with you for a long time, are doing good work and you still have them on starting wages. And that isn't an issue that has anything to do with the minimum wage.

You've got nothing to support that thesis except your own strongly held opinion and maybe some data from some industry lobbyists.
 

treedancer

Commander
Joined
Apr 10, 2005
Messages
2,216
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Here is a little more data to throw into the mix. Since inflation has eroded wages the minimum wage in the present century is $2 lower in real dollars than it was four decades ago and now stands the lowest its been since1955, according to the economic policy institute and center on budget and policy priorities.

Our elected officials are rather quite on the issue. Maybe that's because they didn't want to draw attention to the fact that they raise their own salaries almost every year while refusing to raise the pay of our lowest-paid workers.

It seems to me corporate America and the bush administration are in lock step in keeping the wages of working men and women at the lowest end of the wage scale.

Here is some more Statistics , the minimum wage has varied from a maximum of 90% of the poverty level in 1968 and has been between 53 and 62% since 1985. This is the lowest percentage since the poverty level was established in 1959.


For example, it's impossible to deny that the national minimum wage of $5.15 is not enough for a family to live above the poverty line. The annual salary for workers earning the national minimum wage still leaves a family of three about $6,000 short of the poverty threshold.

Where did I get most of this info you ask? Well where better than here in custombycrunch(call me crunch),s back yard of course.

http://oregonstate.edu/instruct/anth484/minwage.html
 

JasonJ

Rear Admiral
Joined
Aug 20, 2001
Messages
4,163
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Alden, it has nothing to do with being motivated. They live here for the same reason I live here, it is a great place to live. The price to be paid for this great place to live is the lack of industry. So we do what we can to stay here. Perhaps I should have made that part clear, sorry about that.

It still comes back to my original post. It doesn't matter how motivated or educated you are. There are only so many good paying jobs, I don't understand why people are confused on this subject. Yes, there are lazy people out there who only want to do the bare minimum to get by, I get that. There are also people who work their butts off doing what is available to them. In case people havn't known this, it costs money to relocate. Often times the jobs that are at another location that pay more are few and far between, or the cost of living in that area offsets the increase in income. In anotherwords, people get stuck. Its easy for us to sit here and argue this point. The fact that we are here means we make enough money to enjoy the luxury of the subject matter that brought us to this site in the first place. You just go and tell a single mother of three to just "get off your butt and relocate, and everything will be just dandy". It does not work that way.

OB, I could not agree with you more. The rampant breeding going on in this country, especially among the poor and working poor is disgraceful. The money they spend on beer and cigarettes could pay for birth control. I do concede that there is a significant percentage of the populace that brings their problems on themselves. They lack the responsibility to realized that kids cost money. I have always found it interesting that the more intelligent and economically stable a couple is, the less kids they push out.

Aquaman brings up a valid point. Just what is the minimum standard of living. That it relatively easy. A safe home that provides adequate room for its occupants. Reliable transportation to and from work, whether it be the subway in New Work or a ten year old car in Wyoming. Adequate food and cloths. Is it the job of the guvment to provide this base? No. It is up to the individual. On that same token, if a person decides to operate a business where he is employing other people, it is his responsibility to pay a fair wage for the work provided.

As an employer, you affect the lives of those who work for you. They are not pieces of equipment that are turned off at the end of the day, they are people who depend on you to do your job. Employers forget that they need those employees as much as the employees need them. People are not expendable. It costs companies a ton of cash to keep retraining people. If they would just pay better, they would not lose as much money, and the smart employers know this. The greedy bottom-liners don't see this.

I can also see Customs point. If I was making X amount of money, and the minimum wage brought the earnings of a new employee up to my level, I would want more money as well. Thats a hard one to get around, because it could cause the paradox of raising prices to compensate. This comes back to the smart employer. He should look at his business and see if it is running efficiently. Reduce waste, raise the wages with the extra cash. Train the employees better. Make them be more productive. There are ways to do this without jacking prices. I have friends who own business, they did this, and it has worked. Prices were not jacked. They cut the slackers loose, rasied wages, and hired those who could do the job better.

Which brings us right back to the unskilled laborer. How much is he really worth? This can get as mind-numbing as time travel....
 

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Which brings us right back to the unskilled laborer. How much is he really worth?

Truly unskilled?... 0

A worker that can read and write?.. do simple math in their head?.... physicaly do the work? WHAT EVER THE LOCAL MARKET VALUE IS.
 

RubberFrog

Rear Admiral
Joined
Apr 9, 2005
Messages
4,268
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

I thought truly unskilled workers were laborers.... dig here... dig there....
 

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

I've actually had "unskilled labor" that could mess that up! :} 8)
 

Pony

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 27, 2004
Messages
4,355
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

waterinthefuel said:
Oh, and please don't give me some sob story about someone working a minimum wage job because they can't find anything else. Look in the paper. Look online. With 4.4 percent unemployment, which is considered full employment, there are numerous jobs available. You'll just have to work harder than you would flipping a quarter pound slab of beef on its back every so often. Heck, in the past couple of months we've hired 5 or 6 new zero experience people at twice minimum wage, and we're a small mom and pop operation in Louisiana, a state known for low wages and poor citizens.

.

I take it you have never actually been in that positition. If you ever have been you would know you are talking out of you ass.

Maybe you didnt read my post above when I said that she sent out resume after resume. Searching the paper and going to interview after interview. There was NOTHING. Its called being over qualified. If you made it and worked hard to get out, thats great for you...........but I can tell you her not getting those jobs wasnt because she want trying. She looked. Cried heself to sleep after losing jobs to younger workers who the company didnt have to pay as much, spent hours going through job ads, sending countless resumes to places that werent even hiring. Took 2 years for that work to pay off. Believe it or not it can happen that way. Its not all welfare luvin apathetic losers.

I'm done with this thread.......those of you who don't get it, never will. I'm not talking about the minimum wage thing, I am talking about the fact that some of you thing the ONLY reason people take minimum wage jobs is laziness and lack of will. Get off of your high horse and come back to reality.

So go ahead......flame away. I agree that welfare is often taken advantage of and is incentive not to work. I hate lazy people and work my butt of at work every day and expect that of the people under me. But this isnt about welfare, its about minimum wage.

I am not so nieve to think I don't have a lot of learning to do. I am young, I have a lot to see.
 

crunch

Commander
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
2,844
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

I said that she sent out resume after resume. Searching the paper and going to interview after interview. There was NOTHING. Its called being over qualified.

I can certainly sympathize with that, It's one of the reasons I grew up poor.

My stepfather had masters in Physics, Geology, Chemistry, and Math.... and his teaching credentials. Only job he could find was substitute.

He did manage to build, stick by stick a very nice home for us and we kept the ranch together. They finally sold it when land values were high and managed to retire gracefully, not rich, but they do ok.

Hopefully your mom will do as well.
 

BoatBuoy

Rear Admiral
Joined
May 29, 2004
Messages
4,856
Re: Don't raise the minimum wage!!!

Pony, you've probably figured it out already, but "over-qualified" is just another way for business repukes to circumvent age discrimination laws.
 
Top