Two topics here. First off is where do I find sheet foam? I pulled out a bunch of this stuff from between the stringers under the deck:
It's about 2" thick and 12" wide. I walked around Lowes this morning with no luck.
Second, I found some screws this morning that were labeled for attaching wood to metal. They have a tip that looks like a metal boring screw - like a drill bit - and the rest is like a tight thread wood screw. I'm planning on pre-drilling the holes in the wood, filling them with silicon, and then drilling, in order to preserve the seal on the wood. Think these will do the trick? They aren't stainless, so I shouldn't have any issues with the aluminum.

It's about 2" thick and 12" wide. I walked around Lowes this morning with no luck.
Second, I found some screws this morning that were labeled for attaching wood to metal. They have a tip that looks like a metal boring screw - like a drill bit - and the rest is like a tight thread wood screw. I'm planning on pre-drilling the holes in the wood, filling them with silicon, and then drilling, in order to preserve the seal on the wood. Think these will do the trick? They aren't stainless, so I shouldn't have any issues with the aluminum.