tv warranty of not?

rsw21282

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jan 25, 2009
Messages
122
I have been looking at the lcd vs plasma forum and it seems pretty split so im not gonna get into that. My question is, most of the ppl with problems on there are after 2yrs, which is the typical warranty period for most tv's. So is it a good idea to pay 50,75,100 bucks for a warranty for a new tv or is that a corporate scam? Also if anyone wants to give a desired brand of tv that would be helpful, lately i have been wondering about the quality of a insignia tv?
 

joed

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Sep 28, 2002
Messages
1,135
Re: tv warranty of not?

That's cheap. It might be worth it for that price. They wanted over $200 when I bought mine for the extended warranty. I'll take a chance.
 

WIMUSKY

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 26, 2009
Messages
20,045
Re: tv warranty of not?

I've never been one to buy extended warranties on anything. I think they're a waste of money. IMO. I don't know about the Insignia. If I were to buy one right now, I would get a Samsung. They're supposed to be one of the better brands and rival Sony. I've seen them side by side with other brands and Samsung seemed to have the best quality pic.
 

Knightgang

Lieutenant
Joined
Oct 6, 2003
Messages
1,428
Re: tv warranty of not?

Some Insignia models that I looked at before were previous year model LGs (If I remember right) that were rebadged to Insignia. That was a year ago (almost) so I am not sure what they are doing now. I would assume that they are still rebadging previous models form other MFG. In fact, I am pretty sure they are LGs...
 

HopeSheFloats

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jun 12, 2009
Messages
1,674
Re: tv warranty of not?

Our last TV{samsung rear projection 47"} used our extended warranty like the Mrs at the mall with our credit card. We were glad we bought it as 'this one' was a lemon, though it lasted 5&1/2 years with repairs lol.

Our current TV is a Insignia LCD37-09, 37" ...flat panel or whatever you call these wall huggers nowadays. We like it for what we paid for it, the only complaint is black looks way off at times and pixelated{is that a word, lol} blotchy is how I would describe it, and from what I've read seems fairly standard at this $ level... Hope this helps...not knocking either brand as we've had and seen others from these lines that were fine.
 

Whoopbass

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jun 29, 2006
Messages
653
Re: tv warranty of not?

I always hear never buy extended warranty's so that's what I do.

If you want a good deal on a plasma go to ebay then type in Panasonic viera.
My viera is almost 2 years old and it works perfect.

This tv is $630 to your door or possibly less if you submit an offer.
http://cgi.ebay.com/Panasonic-Viera...ions?hash=item20ad57545a&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14
Smokin Deal... I would e-mail the Seller and ask questions just to make sure nothing funny is going on.

I checked his feedback and he sold a new 50" Viera plasma to a guy for $735 plus $30 shipping ( it was originally $825 or best offer). He still has two left so maybe you can get the same deal.
 

cougar1985

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Oct 7, 2005
Messages
1,023
Re: tv warranty of not?

extended warranties are a scam.if your going to have any problems they usually surface within the first year or less.i got a 50 inch panasonic vierra and i love it (plasma)and a 32 inch lcd cinaplex(sp?) in the garage which is equally good and is 4 years trouble free so far.
 

jacknbella

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 8, 2008
Messages
251
Re: tv warranty of not?

5 years ago, I bought a 52" Toshiba DLP at Best Buy for $4K and dished out another $300 for an extended warranty and BOY AM I GLAD I DID!!!

The darn thing kept burning up lamps (come to find out, it was a known problem with those TV's) then one day, something inside gave way rendering the TV dead. Best Buy sent a technician out and confirmed the motherboard fried for no apparent reason. Thankfully, I had an extended warranty because Best Buy gave me a $4K credit at their store to buy any TV at equal or lesser value. Therefore, I bought the top-of-the-line Samsung 50" Plasma FREE OF CHARGE, minus the $300 extended warranty from the original TV. Needless to say, I purchased another $300 extended warranty on the new plasma... Will it be a waste of money, who knows???
 

dolluper

Captain
Joined
Jul 19, 2004
Messages
3,904
Re: tv warranty of not?

Extended could be good but ask questions like manufacture warrenty is one year does the extended warranty start on day 1 or after the Manufactors warrenty ....most start on day one be carefull example 3 year extended is in fact only 2 extra years read the fine print just don't take the SALESMANS word
 

chuckz

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Messages
625
Re: tv warranty of not?

Ask if it's an in home warranty. If you have a large TV you don't want to be shipping the unit out or carrying it to the store for repairs.

I bought a 52" LCD two weeks ago. A 2 year in home warranty was $100.00.

FYI Sharp has made a concerted effort to regain market share by cutting their prices. Their TV's absolutely perform with the very best. You may have to dig a little for reviews because they are rarely reviewed side by side with the much more expensive Samsungs and Sonys.
 

Pony

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 27, 2004
Messages
4,355
Re: tv warranty of not?

extended warranties are a scam.if your going to have any problems they usually surface within the first year or less.i got a 50 inch panasonic vierra and i love it (plasma)and a 32 inch lcd cinaplex(sp?) in the garage which is equally good and is 4 years trouble free so far.

Did you see Roscoe's thread not far below this about his Sony blowing a ine a pixels? That was after the manufacture warranty but before the 2 yr mark........I bet you he wishes he had a service plan.

They are not a scam. I have reaped the benefit myself, and have seen hundreds of others as well. If nothing goes wrong with your TV, yeah they weren't worth it......but.....IF something does they can be a lifesaver. That $100-$200 upfront doesn't look that bad when its 3.5 years later and you are getting a brand new TV because it was too expensive to fix yours.
 

Pony

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 27, 2004
Messages
4,355
Re: tv warranty of not?

Extended could be good but ask questions like manufacture warrenty is one year does the extended warranty start on day 1 or after the Manufactors warrenty ....most start on day one be carefull example 3 year extended is in fact only 2 extra years read the fine print just don't take the SALESMANS word

Even though you may not think of it, starting on day 1 isn't always a bad thing or a rip off. It makes it easier to deal with the manufacture if you do have an issues. It takes 4-6 weeks on average to get exchange approval for a manufacture warranty issue. A lot of times if you have the service plan (its not a warranty btw) the store can help with/ expidite that process.

Still most issues arise in years 2-4, and many of the plans are 4 yr plans...........
 

Pony

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 27, 2004
Messages
4,355
Re: tv warranty of not?

Some Insignia models that I looked at before were previous year model LGs (If I remember right) that were rebadged to Insignia. That was a year ago (almost) so I am not sure what they are doing now. I would assume that they are still rebadging previous models form other MFG. In fact, I am pretty sure they are LGs...

This year some are made by Samsung.....but in the past they have been LG's. They have actually been ranked very well in consumer reports from a value standpoint. I am a little partial to them because I sell them, but I do own one myself and the picture quality for the price is great.
 

Pony

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 27, 2004
Messages
4,355
Re: tv warranty of not?

I have been looking at the lcd vs plasma forum and it seems pretty split so im not gonna get into that. My question is, most of the ppl with problems on there are after 2yrs, which is the typical warranty period for most tv's. So is it a good idea to pay 50,75,100 bucks for a warranty for a new tv or is that a corporate scam? Also if anyone wants to give a desired brand of tv that would be helpful, lately i have been wondering about the quality of a insignia tv?

One of the nice features of the Insignia is that they have a 2 year manufacture warranty and as if two years of warranty coverage were not enough.......for 30” or greater, Best Buy will offer a complimentary 37” 1080p loaner TV if an Insignia television cannot be repaired on the first technician’s visit.

A 2/4 year plan on an Insignia is less expensive as a result of this.......
 

lowkee

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 13, 2008
Messages
1,890
Re: tv warranty of not?

On the extended warranty, I would say it depends on the price of the item and how much you researched it.

If the Television costs >$1000 and the extended warranty is in-house and only costs, say, $100, and you plan to keep the television for many years, I would say it is worth it, even though most times the warranty is a scam (FYI: most retail outfits now make more from exteneded warranties than the items they sell). I consider extended warranties to be in-line with home refinancing. If you plan to stay put for many years, it can be worth it. If you plan to sell it and move on 2-3 years down the road, why bother? Another caveat is research. You get what you pay for, including in televisions, and if you buy some pretty glossy beveled display on a whim without checking out ongoing issues and customer complaints, you should buy the warranty as an "Ignorant Consumer tax", as for all you know, those television sets are well-known to die 5 days after warranty or have a factory warranty which covers nearly nothing.

I bought a 61" JVC (HD 61FN97) rear projection set after much research (I literally kidnapped a laptop from the notebook section and did an hour of research while at Best Buy, then went home and spent the night doing comparisons to other, more expensive, sets). I opted to forgo the extended warranty, simply because I found this to be a reliable, well-respected set with few customer issues, none being covered by either warranty. I could have gotten a set which died 10 days out of warranty, but then again, by then a better set would be out and if you factor in the $200 they wanted for a warranty on a $1100 set (it was a return), I would rather pony up the $750 if the sets dies prematurely (but after the two-year warranty) instead of dishing out insurance money for something which will likely die well within two years if something was bad to begin with. These aren't exactly high wear items we're talking about. It sits against the wall and glows.
 

cougar1985

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Oct 7, 2005
Messages
1,023
Re: tv warranty of not?

Did you see Roscoe's thread not far below this about his Sony blowing a ine a pixels? That was after the manufacture warranty but before the 2 yr mark........I bet you he wishes he had a service plan.

They are not a scam. I have reaped the benefit myself, and have seen hundreds of others as well. If nothing goes wrong with your TV, yeah they weren't worth it......but.....IF something does they can be a lifesaver. That $100-$200 upfront doesn't look that bad when its 3.5 years later and you are getting a brand new TV because it was too expensive to fix yours.

it has been proven time and time again that the odds are heavly stacked against ever using a tv extended warrenty.if it makes you fell better go for it ,me, i will apply my money else wheres as ive never ,repeat never had a problem .
 

Pony

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 27, 2004
Messages
4,355
Re: tv warranty of not?

it has been proven time and time again that the odds are heavly stacked against ever using a tv extended warrenty.if it makes you fell better go for it ,me, i will apply my money else wheres as ive never ,repeat never had a problem .

Ok you have never had a problem, that is great for you. But to say it has been proven time and time again is a very bold statement.....and I sort of question where you are drawing that conclussion from.

I am in the business. I deal with customers who have TV issues EVERY day. It happens more than you would think.....just because it hasn't happened to you or someone you are close to doesn't mean it doesn't happen.
 

204 Escape

Ensign
Joined
Nov 17, 2007
Messages
909
Re: tv warranty of not?

I was given brand new a SHARP AQUOS 30" flat screen TV for some work that I did. We have had it for almost 3 years, if my memory serves me right. It has an excellant picture !!!! AND, the price was right !!!!!!! I also got a SONY surround sound system too. I'd suggest a SHARP. We also have a Samsung, in the bedroom, BUT, it is only a 20". BUT, it was free as well. BOTH came with the manf. warrenty, and SO FAR have NOT needed either one, repaired.;)
 

lowkee

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 13, 2008
Messages
1,890
Re: tv warranty of not?

..to say it has been proven time and time again is a very bold statement.....and I sort of question where you are drawing that conclussion from..

From business week (older article):

This fiscal year, Ardor's Kuhrt estimates warranty revenues will deliver 36% of Best Buy's operating profits and all of Circuit City's.

From wikipedia:

Consumer advocate groups, such as the non-profit Consumers Union, advise against purchasing extended warranties. David Butler of the Consumers Union says, "The extended warranty is definitely in the best interest of the company, but isn't often in the best interest of the consumer." He adds, "The company is much more likely to profit from the extended warranty than the consumer is." In many cases, if the item does need repairing, the cost of repairs are less than the cost of the extended warranty. Other advocates also advise against purchasing extended warranties, maintaining that they are a cash cow for retailers, many of whom will refuse to repair items covered under such plans, if at all possible. Furthermore, consumer advocate groups point out that the only way the extended warranty could do any good is if the product breaks down after the standard warranty but before the extended warranty is up, which is unlikely.

Consumers Union says only two products deserve extended warranty consideration: projection TV's and digital cameras. Both are expensive to repair and need repairs frequently.

The bottom line is, if you are trying to save a buck by buying cheap junk which has a high failure rate, why not use the money you would dish out for an extended warranty (normally 20-30% of the price) and buy a higher priced, more reliable, better (factory) warranted item instead?

I am in the business. I deal with customers who have TV issues EVERY day. It happens more than you would think..

Since you are in the business, can you share the percentage of post-factory warranty claims to item sales? How about the percent of extended warranty claims which are actually covered at no cost to the consumer out of the total number of extended warranty sales?

I think you would see a very disfigured balance in those numbers. Being on the floor talking to customers may make it appear to be a heavy warranty rate, but once you figure in total sales and the true number of accepted and no-cost extended warranty claims, it may become a whole new picture. Without those figures, we're all merely guessing, though.
 

cougar1985

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Oct 7, 2005
Messages
1,023
Re: tv warranty of not?

From business week (older article):



From wikipedia:



The bottom line is, if you are trying to save a buck by buying cheap junk which has a high failure rate, why not use the money you would dish out for an extended warranty (normally 20-30% of the price) and buy a higher priced, more reliable, better (factory) warranted item instead?



Since you are in the business, can you share the percentage of post-factory warranty claims to item sales? How about the percent of extended warranty claims which are actually covered at no cost to the consumer out of the total number of extended warranty sales?

I think you would see a very disfigured balance in those numbers. Being on the floor talking to customers may make it appear to be a heavy warranty rate, but once you figure in total sales and the true number of accepted and no-cost extended warranty claims, it may become a whole new picture. Without those figures, we're all merely guessing, though.
GOOD INFO .where did i get my info ?from reading ,and looking on the net a lot before i bought .have i ever bought a extended warrenty ,you bet i have till i found out the actual vs PERCIEVED claims.being in the bussiness may mean your a salesperson and you may or maynot have a vested interest in selling a warrenty.i can honestly say i dont know one person who has had a tv failure unless that tv was old junk.i do know several people who left certian stores because they tried to hard to push extended warrenty,s on them also.consumers report and several other publications had very good articals on why extended warrenties we generally no good for squat.dont take my word for it read about it for yourself people and make up your own minds.remember one thing ,depending on where you go, the person you talk to makes their living by selling as much as they can.
 
Top