Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

blu72nova

Recruit
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
5
I am currently starting to seriously look for a new boat. I am interested in an aluminum boat. I have looked at the tracker pro team 175 TXW. I like the layout of the boat with the raised decks and the ample storage. I also like the depth finder and trolling motor as standard options. However, I have not had much experience with different boat brands, therefore I have no preference of one brand over another. I am interested in peoples preferences for aluminum boats similar to the tracker mentioned. My price range is about $15K. I fish mainly on small to medium size lakes so top speed is not a priority. I am interested in stability and smoothness of ride. Any input is appreciated. Thanks!
 

Rumley

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Dec 5, 2009
Messages
105
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Take a look at Lund. They are more expensive but you get what you pay for. The lifetime warranty on the hull is a great feature and the ride quality is unmatched. A pro sport sounds similar to what you want or for more money the tyee or fisherman are beautiful boats.
 

dave11

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Dec 2, 2007
Messages
1,195
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I have an Alumaweld. It is a great boat, but will be out of your price range, unless you want to keep it for a long time.

Lund makes a really nice boat. Also a little pricey.

Take a look at Starcraft. They have been around a long time, and they make a good boat.
 

reelfishin

Captain
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
3,050
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I have a neighbor with an older Pro 16 bass boat that has had several hull issues, the latest has been a bend in the hull just ahead of the transom. It looks like someone picked the boat up and slammed it down over a pipe about 9" in front of the transom, the entire hull shows this bend, the bottom curves up towards the transom and the top rail raises up. He only runs small water with it and it's on a flat bunk trailer well supported.
He had other issues with cracking welds around the corner bracing or gussets as well back when it was newer.
It's an ok looking boat but had always took max hp to make it move, the 25hp it came with was a joke, yet it flies on my 14' boat. He finally hung a Merc Classic 50 on it a few years ago, which may have had something to do with the transom/hull bending but the boat is rated at 55hp on the Coast Guard plate.

I've seen other hull issues with Tracker boats, they're a low end boat, and you get what you pay for. I equate the Tracker brand with the likes of Bayliner and other entry level brands.
 

Boatist

Rear Admiral
Joined
Apr 22, 2002
Messages
4,552
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Also take a look at Crestliner.
I had mine since 1980 and love it.
They have from bass boats and also some that are good for bass and convert to a family ski and picknic boat.

http://www.crestliner.com/

I would not buy a Aluminum boat with rivet as it is a hull drag and if run big waters that stress the hull they may start leaking.
I also have a older 1967 Klamath that has rivets and leaks at many rivets.
New Klamath boats are all welded and are great low end boats but I think only sold in the West.
Their web site is there biggest leakness

http://www.klamathboats.com/

When buying a package boat make sure you check the trolling motor.
You want one that has one of the better power saver motors.
They cost a little more but in the long run will save a lot of battery power and life.
Same with Depth Finder and GPS make sure you get the type you want even if a little more.
 

fishrdan

Admiral
Joined
Jan 25, 2008
Messages
6,989
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Last I checked, Tracker boats has an "exterior weld" warranty,,, if the boat has weld problems below deck your SOL for warranty repair... :rolleyes:

My 2007 Tracker jon boat has cracked welds on the transom corners, so I'm not a fan of the brand. And, I'm only running 75% of the hull HP rating.

I checked every weld in the 01 Crestliner I'm rebuilding (since I had all the decks out) and everything was a'OK.
 

TexMojo

Seaman
Joined
Oct 30, 2009
Messages
62
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I've had tracker and bayliner boats and really never had issues. I think its the users and maintenance that give them a bad rep.
 

slasmith1

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
1,028
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I've had tracker and bayliner boats and really never had issues. I think its the users and maintenance that give them a bad rep.

^^^^^^^^
what he said!
 

5150abf

Vice Admiral
Joined
Aug 12, 2007
Messages
5,808
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Not to dog on a brand but I have seen numerous posts about bad welds and quality in general on the tracker boats and since that is what holds them together maybe look at a different brand.

Maybe to stretch your budget don't look at new go a couple years old then you can go up market without going up budget too much.
 

TexMojo

Seaman
Joined
Oct 30, 2009
Messages
62
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I'm not defending any brand of boat but I often wonder how much of the bad rep is water cooler talk. I would like to actually see owners or previous owners of said boats versus people who read or hear that a certain brand of boat is bad. Bottom line is I will listen or take into consideration a post from a person who has first hand experience, ie boat owner, versus someone who just simply labels a brand and they have no first hand knowledge of that brand. Off the soap box. LOL
 

TexMojo

Seaman
Joined
Oct 30, 2009
Messages
62
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I am currently starting to seriously look for a new boat. I am interested in an aluminum boat. I have looked at the tracker pro team 175 TXW. I like the layout of the boat with the raised decks and the ample storage. I also like the depth finder and trolling motor as standard options. However, I have not had much experience with different boat brands, therefore I have no preference of one brand over another. I am interested in peoples preferences for aluminum boats similar to the tracker mentioned. My price range is about $15K. I fish mainly on small to medium size lakes so top speed is not a priority. I am interested in stability and smoothness of ride. Any input is appreciated. Thanks!

Sorry for the last post, I got off on a tangent. I truly think you haven't provided enough information, what type of fishing, your age, how many people. I am a previous tracker owner and I liked the ride but my knees didn't like the decks so I switched to a glass Center Console. Tracker boats are reasonably priced compared to other brands but they do skimp on the engines when it comes to their package deals. If your going to finance a tracker and don't have alot of income that can outfit the boat, have it all installed during the purchase process. Just my opinion. Get the max HP that the boat will handle versus what they are offering. Yeah, its all going to raise the price but you don't want to buy something your not happy with in a few years. Glass versus Alum is another decision. In general, Glass rides smoother but alum is lighter and easier to beach but this all depends on alot of variatons. If your only concern is a smooth ride and stability, find a decent used glass boat with a good engine that has already been outfitted and I think you will come out cheaper and in better shape. Good Luck
 

blu72nova

Recruit
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
5
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Thanks for everyone's input! As for a little more information about myself (in reference to the last post) I'm in my mid 20's and will mainly be fishing with my father in law who is in his late 50's. We mainly fish for bass and crappie. I don't plan on fishing with more than 3 people on the boat at a time.

Also, in the areas we fish (lakes in east TN) there are plenty of boat ramps so I don't think the outboard motor size is much of an issue. I've been in boats with smaller motors (35 hp, and a slightly smaller boat) and it has been sufficient for me.

Someone, also mentioned the power saver trolling motors. That sounds like a good idea, but I really don't know anything about them. Could someone give some input on some makes and models that would work well for this size of a boat. Once again, thanks for everyone's input!!
 

roscoe

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Oct 30, 2002
Messages
21,750
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Someone, also mentioned the power saver trolling motors. That sounds like a good idea, but I really don't know anything about them. Could someone give some input on some makes and models that would work well for this size of a boat. Once again, thanks for everyone's input!!

My concern is that by the time you fuel up and add your people and gear, you will be at about 1600#, quite heavy for a 50hp to get up on plane.


Minn Kota makes trolling motors with "Maximizer" feature. Works by pulsing the energy on and off. Works well and extends trolling battery life by hours.

I would get a motor with 50 - 65# of thrust. Lots of models and features to pick from.
 

fishrdan

Admiral
Joined
Jan 25, 2008
Messages
6,989
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I think its the users and maintenance that give them a bad rep.

Hmmm, I'll let you be the judge. 2 year old boat, 75% of hull HP rating, transom saver used,, but the transom corner gusset welds still cracked...

Trackers teeny tiny transom plywood... (no knee braces?)
dscf2588.jpg


Fishrdan's rebuilt transom that hasn't allowed the bad welds to crack any further
dscf2593.jpg

dscf2606.jpg

dscf2604.jpg
 

reelfishin

Captain
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
3,050
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

The boat I was referring to is an older model, which has a splash well, transom knee braces and a full wood panel which goes nearly to the bottom the the hull. The boat has had a few gusset cracks but they have been re-welded. The bent hull occurred recently. There is also signs of corrosion on that hull, much more than I'd expect from a freshwater boat.
From what I see and hear, it's a brand to stay away from unless your just after a boat to use as a starter boat and dump it after a few years. I'd have to be pretty desperate for a boat to go looking for a Tracker after seeing first hand what my neighbor and several others here have gone through. I can understand why some of those boats crack after seeing the transom construction, but for a hull to sag or bend like this one, there's just no excuse.
Years ago I had a Grumman bass boat which I bought used, it was rated at 35hp, and I hung a fresh 35 hp motor on it, the boat was fast, faster than I needed it to be. Being young, I did stupid things to that boat. I can remember jumping wakes and running it aground at speed quite often, it got beached regularly, tied up for weeks at a time and run in the river with ice chunks slamming the hull the whole way out. It never leaked, never cracked, and never showed any signs of how bad I treated it. The floor eventually needed replacing, but long after I sold it. Looking back over the years, knowing what I do now from years of experience, that boat should have darn near broke in two or sunk. I can remember hitting huge wakes and having so much hang time I could look back and and all around before it crashed back down. Being a flat bottom modified V bass boat, it would pound every time. I also can remember having to chisel it out of the ice one winter after it froze in the lake, I had loaned it to a buddy farther north who let it sit all fall and all winter in the water. When I got it out, it had a foot of ice in the boat and was nearly frozen to the lake surface. We chipped it out with iron bars and dragged it across the ice to the boat ramp with a quad. It was fine come spring. Even the motor survived somehow. 25 years later I'd never think of doing half of the things I did to that boat. I'd still like to find another one like it now. I always regretted selling that boat. The new Grumman boats are quite different than the original ones. The one I had had an all welded hull with round gunwale rails which were like bumpers. They never dented and never flexed. That boat was solid and very rigid.
 

Silvertip

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,771
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

On a 17 foot or less boat you do not need a 65# thrust troller unless the vast majority of your fishing is in very high wind. Besides, anything over 55# from any of the manufacturers puts you in the 24 volt range which requires two 12 volt batteries which adds weight. A 50 HP motor will provide only marginal performance with a maximum load. The number of boat ramps in your area has nothing to do with engine HP. Any boat that is powered with an engine that is less than 75% of the boats maximum rated HP will be a marginal performer and will likely consume more fuel than a bigger engine. Remember, a small engine working at nearly full capacity will burn as much fuel as a big engine that is loafing. In my area the three top names in aluminum boats are Lund, Alumacraft, and Crestliner. Alumacraft can be ordered as a "no pre-rig" boat which means you order the boat without the engine. This allows you to buy whatever engine you like rather than being stuck with whatever the boat manufacturer packages with the boat. You buy the engine wherever the desired brand is sold.
 

T Wardy

Cadet
Joined
Oct 20, 2009
Messages
15
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I just bought an Alumacraft.....quality wise right there with a Lund. This is the model I got which may be right up your alley in stock trim.

http://alumacraft.com/deluxe-side-console-boats/classic-165-cs-2.php

Although I made some major upgrades including a 60hp Merc 4 Stroke, 70Lb thrust 24 volt Minn Kota with Co-Pilot and AUto pilot, On board charger (3 Bank) and moved the cheap depth finder they provide to the bow and had a Humminbird 70ci color GPS installed on the dash......:)

But.....in stock trim it's a damn good boat and the quality is MILES ahead of a tracker. I owned a tracker once an my personal opinion is that the boat is ok but everything else they put in them is JUNK.;)
 

blu72nova

Recruit
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
5
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Thanks for everyone's input. It really helps to hear from people who have had experience with different types of boats.
 

Scooby-doo72

Recruit
Joined
Jul 13, 2009
Messages
3
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I have a older (96) 17ft Tracker, and have never had any problems with it. I dont know if the brand has gone down hill in quality over the years
 

Big Fish Billy

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Dec 31, 2009
Messages
301
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I am currently starting to seriously look for a new boat. I am interested in an aluminum boat. I have looked at the tracker pro team 175 TXW. I like the layout of the boat with the raised decks and the ample storage. I also like the depth finder and trolling motor as standard options. However, I have not had much experience with different boat brands, therefore I have no preference of one brand over another. I am interested in peoples preferences for aluminum boats similar to the tracker mentioned. My price range is about $15K. I fish mainly on small to medium size lakes so top speed is not a priority. I am interested in stability and smoothness of ride. Any input is appreciated. Thanks!

My friend has the Tracker, and I can say I love it, not sure the motor size but it flies with 4 couples in it out for a booze cruise. No leaks, plenty of comfortable seating. I think it's a 2006 and new he paid $6,000 for boat, motor and trailer, hell of a deal. I recently saw the same boat on Craig's List for $2,900, that would have been a better deal. Now I also have a friend with a Lund, bilge pump runs full time because of the rivets leaking...go Tracker.

Bill
 
Top