Help Needed regarding Torsion Axels and Keel Bunks

golf101

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jan 18, 2009
Messages
182
I'm getting a lot of conflicting information from trailer manufacturers about two issues: (1) the pros and cons of torsion axles vs. leaf axles; and (2) whether a boat needs to be supported by the keel. The manufacturers who make aluminum trailers seem to advocate torsion axles and no keel support, and the manufacturers who make painted and galvanized trailers seem to advocate the opposite. Is one better than the other?
 

Silvertip

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,771
Re: Help Needed regarding Torsion Axels and Keel Bunks

The keel is the strongest part of the boat so the boat should be supported by it with lateral support provided by the bunks. However, the location of the longitudinal frame members in the boat in relation to the bunks has a lot to do with support as well. If the boat has a strong longitudinal frame member directly over a bunk, less keel support is needed and launching/retrieval may be easier. If there are no frame members directly over or at least close to the bunks then more support is provided by the keel. So hull design has a lot to do with how the trailer should be set up.

Torsion axles are just fine for a single axle trailer but there is one issue with them on a tandem or tri-axle. That issue is there is no equalizer like there is on a leaf sprung trailer so a multi-axle torsion axle trailer must be towed dead level or there is a risk of overloading an axle/tire in uneven pavement such as leaving or entering a driveway or parking lot. Consider one wheel having to step over an object placed in front of it. With the lack of an equalizer, that one wheel picks up a considerable amount of weight in the process. On a lightly loaded trailer that's not an issue. But since most boat trailers tend to be loaded close to their maximum, that can burst a tire or damage the cords. I have seen tandem torsion axles with one set of wheels totally off the ground. The latest incident was on a paved road intersection that had a moderate elevation change from one road to the other. In that scenario, one axle must suddenly support the entire load thus almost certainly presenting an overload condition.
 

H20Rat

Vice Admiral
Joined
Mar 8, 2009
Messages
5,204
Re: Help Needed regarding Torsion Axels and Keel Bunks

for a single axle trailer though, there is no comparison. Torsion axle trailers ride vastly better than a leaf spring bouncing around.
 

TilliamWe

Banned
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
6,579
Re: Help Needed regarding Torsion Axels and Keel Bunks

...I have seen tandem torsion axles with one set of wheels totally off the ground...

silvertip pretty much covers it all spot on. I did want to add in respect to this point only, though: I have seen this exact phenomenon too, but I have also seen it on a tandem axle spring type trailer as well. Now, the elevation/angle change was pretty steep (it was at the top of a moderately steep ramp), but it can still happen with a spring suspension. It happens less often, though.
 

Fl_Richard

Lieutenant
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
1,428
Re: Help Needed regarding Torsion Axels and Keel Bunks

I've got tandums and I''l take the chance of a blowout over leaf spring any day. Less hardware, less maintenence and a smooth ride trump the disadvantages for me.
 
Top