Spring Break :o)

Toddo1

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Feb 10, 2007
Messages
32
A friend broke a leaf spring on his single axle trailer. The tire caught the fender and consequently rolled the axle towards the rear on that side and needless to say it instantly became a very dangerous situation. Fortunately, he was going slow enough that he could pull over without incident.

That got me to thinking...(since this could happen to me at 65mph) what if I bolted a piece of chain to the axle (just inside each spring) and bolted the other end to the trailer frame somewhere ahead of the axle (keeping some slack of course). This chain would keep the axle under the trailer in basically the same position in the event of a catastrophic spring failure. What I'm asking is... if this would work , why haven't I seen anything like it before?
 

bruceb58

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 5, 2006
Messages
30,587
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

While you are at it do the same thing on your car because it is just as likely to happen there. All kidding aside, this is just so rare that it just isn't necessary. I have this funny feeling that his springs were corroded to begin with and probably should have been replaced or an inspection would have indicated a potential problem.
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,089
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

Ayuh,... For that very reason is Why most of Us do regular Maintanance....

I'd rather find an Issue, before it becomes a Problem...
 

rjlipscomb

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jun 2, 2009
Messages
582
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

Todd,

Once again, you are reminding everyone, at least those of us that read this post, that we need to thoroughly inspect our trailers and tow vehicles before heading off to the 1st launch of this year's season. I'm pretty sure, the boats will have been looked at fairly well. But that thing underneath that rolls, we usually figure it'll be okay since it is always on land, meaning we don't depend on it to get us back to shore.

THANKS! :)
 

Toddo1

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Feb 10, 2007
Messages
32
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

I do agree that regular maintenance/inspection is paramount. I do take my trailering very seriously.

I was just fearing that an unseen stress crack could become a disaster. My friends spring cracked just at the edge of the ubolt plate. They didn't show signs of excessive corrosion. They were the original springs, not cheap replacement ones from china and they were the correct weight for the load (not overloaded).
 

Pez Vela

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Dec 4, 2004
Messages
504
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

Having suffered the same, and living through it, I later asked my trailer manufacturer what probably happened, since my leaf springs looked to be in decent shape. He told me that it was very likely that the u-bolts failed first, leading to a cascading chain of events, which resulted in a broken leaf spring, an axle running at 45? to the trailer frame, smoke billowing out from tires, and a near catastrophe. He recommended that the u-bolts be changed out periodically as a part of my routine maintenance.
 

642mx

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Apr 19, 2008
Messages
1,588
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

I had a leaf spring break last summer on my single axle. I was 3 hours away from home when it did it. I didn't hit anything hard, had no warning signs, no corrosion, no paint missing and the trailer was inspected before I left on the trip...

I'd say its not that uncommon to have this happen. I was lucky enough that the axle didn't shift... 2 of the 4 springs broke so the tire would rub the fender when I would hit a bump, but I was able to limp it to a marina that fitted a block of wood between the frame and axle for me.

When I arrived at my destination, I called around and found a trailer dealer who had the springs in stock and fixed it while I waited. I did upgrade to a 5 leaf system and had both sides replaced.

To the original poster, it never hurts to be prepared. I now carry several straps and a block of wood (along with other things) with me on long trips.
 

reelfishin

Captain
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
3,050
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

I had a brand new trailer break a main leaf spring last year, but it was on a tandem axle trailer with 8 lug wheels, when it broke, the opposite spring was stiff enough to keep the axle from swinging back too far. I actually didn't realize it till I saw smoke in my rear view mirror while stopping. The smoke was from the left forward wheel moving back and hitting the front of the left rear wheel when the axle was pulled back during braking.

Since it was a front spring, the extra weight was held by the truck, which never noticed the added weight, even under the weight of a front end loader.

I also had a spring bolt break on an old somewhat rusty trailer I bought, it was on the way home, heading down the highway with boat and trailer in tow. I had checked the wheel bearings, added some grease and figure it would be OK for the 40 mile ride home. The boat was a junker which I bought only for it's newer motor so I didn't much care about the boat or trailer, and if the seller would have let me, I'd have stripped the controls and motor off it and left it.

The springs were rusty, but not so much that they looked unsafe. What broke was the left front bolt holding the spring to the frame. This happened about 10 miles from home, at about 50 mph, the axle first dropped a bit, I noticed something and slowed down, looking for a place to pull out of traffic, then right after the axle slid back letting the tire hit the frame and back of the fender, that made lots of smoke.
I got off the highway slowly, stopped and looked, the tires had pretty heavy side walls and I was almost home. I stayed off the main freeway and took a back road the rest of the way doing no more than maybe 15 or 20 mile an hour with the thinking that the closer I got to home before the tire blew, the less it would cost me to tow it. It made it all the way to my driveway. The last few miles were with a patrol car following closely with red lights flashing. He told me he wanted to see how far I'd make it on the rim once it blew. It made home but the tire blew when I tried to back up, when the axle swung the other way, the tire then caught the bent forward lip of the fender tore through the already thin corner. There was a pile of smoldering, burnt sticky rubber on the frame and leaf spring, and the tire was down to the cords about 3/4 of the way across and down the inner sidewall. (There was a few bits stuck the patrol car following me too). The other tire which was badly dryrotted, was chopped badly from being drug at a bad angle. I pulled the motor the next day, stripped the boat out and listed it on CL, it was gone by the following weekend, sold for $100 to the first taker.
 

Pez Vela

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Dec 4, 2004
Messages
504
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

I pulled the motor the next day, stripped the boat out and listed it on CL, it was gone by the following weekend, sold for $100 to the first taker.

How much did you get for the tires?
 

roscoe

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Oct 30, 2002
Messages
21,753
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

Spring break? I don't get it. This is spring break.
breaknow.com%20spring%20break%202010%20Cabo.jpg
 

j_martin

Admiral
Joined
Sep 22, 2006
Messages
7,474
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

I broke a back spring hanger on my tandem trailer in Montana, bringing a load of wheat back to Minnesota about 4 years ago. I wrapped a heavy load strap around both axles, pulled till it looked lined up, and hit the road.

I wonder what condition that strap is in. I haven't looked lately.

Seriously, what makes a leaf spring break is a failure mode called corrosion stress cracking. It doesn't take much corrosion to set up a weakness that is amplified by the constant flexing.

In the old days, springs were greased and wrapped. (1940's stuff) If you buy a can of WD40 and empty it on the springs a couple of times a year, you will never break one.

They built a bunch of steel bridges using tempered steel to get the extra strength back in the 30's. 30 years later they began to fail, with one notable catastrophe in the Southeast somewhere I remember about 1965. It turns out that if the paint wasn't religiously maintained, they would fail.
 

Tvmrfixxit

Cadet
Joined
Jun 18, 2009
Messages
8
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

I had the same thing happen to me last spring only I was AT the marina. I was new to this trailer and boat and didn't know about checking springs or that stuff. Broke the lowest plate in half at the pin, wheel was then sitting on the fender. I found a local guy (40 miles one way from the lake) that said he would fix it, so I got a block of wood and cobbled it to get the trailer to him. His repair worked for the rest of our trip, then on the way home it collapsed again (not broken) when I pulled in the driveway, now over 3 hours from the repair shop i'd had it serviced at. He was understanding that I wouldn't want to bring it back and refunded me my full repair bill anyways. I ended up getting another broken spring and rebuilding it myself not hard or pretty but got me thru the rest of the year Now I'm working on replacing springs, rebuilding the hubs and then I will keep up on the maintainance from here on. Lots to know and do in the off season that I had no idea about, This forum is the greatest thing to ever happen to the world of boating and trailering. Thank you everyone
Jon
 

JimMH

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Sep 4, 2009
Messages
361
Re: Spring Break :eek:)

I had a leaf spring break on a Master Craft trailer 23 years ago and was lucky enough to get a Truck shop to fit a piece of 6X6 between the frame and axel so I could limp home. I was going very slow, in town, and nothing happened other than some fender scrubing. I had a spring break on a utility trailer at HWY speeds about 12 years ago and I almost lost a 4wheeler. I remembered what the truck shop did and looked around and found a large limb on the side of the road and was able to wedge it in until I could get home,150miles, It was 1AM and I was coming home from a Duck Hunting trip.
 
Top