Re: what should be a correct prop size
I guess the "19" in your other thread was a typo?
Just guessing here, but big boat, small engine, 1.5 gear ratio probably left the dealer with something closer to a 17" three blade.
But we still don't know if you throttle is fully opened, boat is carrying extra water weight, etc.
Complete hwsii's worksheet.
And remember, "it has good speed" is diagnosticaly irrelevent. Use real numbers.