Re: 15Hp Evinrude '76 - Appreciate your advice
The King is right on..this is exactly as it should be, the tubes flange goes in the upper grommets groove. In all actuality then the very upper inside diameter of the grommet will not have the tube wall in contact...maybe this was what was meant by the comment that it's unsupported. Anyway, it's pretty stiff so it wont be a problem for many years. Eventually they do get soft and break down, I have seen them collapse and restrict water flow, but you won't have this issue for at least 20 years with just seasonal use.
Be very careful if you replace the water pump grommet, the early engines with square exhaust tubes use the smaller profile grommet. The taller grommet for the pump is for later 15s with round exhaust. The taller grommet will seal against the hole in the bottom of the exhaust housing that the water tube pases through on the earlier models and prevent the housing from draining! So the bigger tall grommet(one of three supplied in the water pump kit) is for 15 round tube exhausts only! Some people have misstakenly posted on their site (Leroys Ramblings)that it does a better job of guiding the lower end of the water tube into the water pump...well it does, but if your engine used the small one , don't replace it with the big one.....been there, done that, learned the hard way.
One other thing, replace the upper mounts now as it's much easier, and a good pre-emptive strike, mine went bad right after fixing my powerhead, and caused me extra work I could have avoided. Repalce the foam seal ring for the lower cowl half too before bolting on the power head. Dip the powerhead and lower unit mounting bolts in OMC sealant or RTV so they don't corrode. You can get touch up paint from BRP in cans, still availlable and makes for a nice job. If yur local shop has the timing arm for setting the points, ask to borrow it and check the timimg. Re-synch the throttle arm to magneto cam setting, see manual. BTW, I use NGK B7-HS plugs, they work just fine and foul less than Champions or I would not use them (I troll quite a bit) Replace the upper crank seal too, now is the time, it will pop out if you tap one side with a brass punch, use a socket to press in the new one with the old one on top of the new one to act as a tool.
You have the best version of the 9.9/15 as it has points and is practically bullet proof. Later models had sucessively more plastic parts that break, and troublesome electronic ingnition "power packs". Mine 1975 has never left me stranded on the lake since I got it in 1978.