Need tech explanation, ignition switch

alden135

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
1,770
Can someone please explain the specifics of how a bad ignition switch can cause a weak spark condition?<br /><br /><br />The usual blah: 1990 J120TLES w/binacle control and dash mounted switch.<br /><br />Thanks
 

Paul Moir

Admiral
Joined
Nov 5, 2002
Messages
6,847
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

I don't know about your outboard, but a while ago Iboats member nordy reverse engineered his 2 cylinder's powerpack after it failed because the potting absorbed moisture.<br /><br />The kill switch circuit was very simple - it just grounded out the main capacitor (the C in CDI) through a 100 ohm resistor. If your kill switch didn't open completely, I mean to say it had some resistance to ground due to moisture or something, it would weaken the output of the powerpack to the ignition coils. The trigger was powered from a seperate circuit so it's functioning would not be affected. Naturally, it would be easy to test for this condition by switching the key to "run", disconnecting the powerpack, and measuring for power or resistance to ground on the kill switch wire.<br /><br />I have no idea if this applies at all to your outboard though. Could be completely different.
 

alden135

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
1,770
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

Thank you both very much. I'll be printing this out and adding it to my manual. It will be helpful for the spring round of the "Why can I only get 3500 rpm? saga"
 

alden135

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
1,770
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

Joe,<br />I would not expect you to remember me with all the people you help, but you and others have helped get this thing from a 1500rpm sea anchor to a boat that at least planes out. <br /><br />Everthing has been replaced/sync'd/comp.tested/rebuilt but the ign. switch and the stator. I have to replace the switch anyway as it sticks in the "start" position. The moisture in the switch theory might be my problem. <br /><br />All cylinders have spark but it's definatly not like you describe. <br /><br />With 125lbs. in each and pretty much a new ign. system I'll have a basicly new engine by spring. I just need to sort out this last issue. <br /><br />Thanks for your help/time.
 

rodbolt

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 1, 2003
Messages
20,066
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

I highly doubt the moisture theory.<br /> I have never seen it. 99% of the time the system sparks or it does not. solid state devices wont get weak. if they work at all they work. that system uses a pair of charge coils to charge a set of capacitors in the powerpack,the trigger circuits use a set of coils to turn on the correct SCR to discharge the capacicor into the correct ign coil primary winding, there is no way a defective key switch can weaken that charge or discharge. it may be possible somehow but I have never seen it.<br /> but if you really wish to test it purchase a CD-77 multimer or its digital equivalent , attach said meter to one of the 4 coil primaries and you will be able to observe ign coil primary voltage. if you have 150 volts or better the system up to the ign coils is working correctly and needs no further testing other than insuring the spark is occuring at the correct time. thats why so many direct injected motors have gone back to a 12v transitorized ign system, you can get a longer spark and multiple sparks out of a 12v system. the alternator driven system does not allow that. once that SCR is triggered it remains in the triggered state until the capacitor is discharged. <br /> what I am thinking is you need to logically trouble shoot and test this motor.<br /> you have been playing with it far to long.<br /> a total system test should take less than 2 hours, hook a vacum gauge up on the fuel pump intake, hook a timing light to #1 cylinder after making sure the timing marks are phsically in the correct position. also index a TDC mark for #2 cylinder. attach the ign coil primary terminal extenders that came with your Cd-77 meter. install the correct test wheel. back it overboard and wind it up to WOT, now you can observe ign timing, watch for fuel restrictions, observe powerpack output and insure the timing for the opposite bank is correct.<br /> the first test is engine compression, if in doubt a leak down test is much more accurate than a compression test. this will verify the mechanical part of the air pump.<br /> next is to insure the triiger is corectly oriented to the crankshaft. in other words make sure the flywheel timin marks agree with where the piston actually is. next you verify that spark is occuring and at the correct time in relation to where the piston actually is. next is to insure the carbs have an adequate supply of fuel.<br /> if the engine has compression, spark at the correct time, fuel actually in the cylinder and exhaust it runs.<br /> its time you stop and assess which portion your missing before you smoke a piston. a test wheel session or a dyno session will isolate a motor problem from a prop/hull problem. an easy test for your switch killing the spark problem is to remove the black yellow wire from the pack connector and retest. if it works its in the kill circuits, if it does not quit playing with kill circuits and move on to the next test in the logical sequence of confirming or eliminating each of the engines subsystems. that engine is very touchy on fuel/air issues. it will lean out and burn a piston without the airbox installed. however if the floats are a tad high it will run rich and not make power.<br /> here again it can be found with a test wheel. while at WOT remove the airbox screws, gently move the airbox away from the airbox mount. if the RPM increases you know its running rich if RPMs drop your on the wrong track. the fuel recirc system normally only affects idle speed, the reed gaskets will occasionally blow out, usually that will have a very adverse affect on idle quality. that 120, if running correctly, will idle in gear in the water at 650 RPM all day long. I idled from kitty hawk to manns harbor and back on a bet last year. collected my 100 bucks and we all had a beer. was about 24 miles of idleing.<br /> I dont wish to appear negative with you but you seem to have been having problems a long time. if you do not have the test equipment and dont wish to purchase it then make a list of the tests you wish your tech to perform and have it done. if your tech does not have the equipment to properly test your machine you have the wrong tech.
 

alden135

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
1,770
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

The problem I have here is the lack of a good dealer. The local one is a rip off artist with a bad rep. I have rarely had a good experience there. Other dealers miles away will order me parts but the local one doesn't want you to fix your own stuff. <br /><br />When I tried to buy a gearcase from the guy he wanted 1500+core for a 20 year old one out back in the grass and wanted another 150 to pressure test it. Needless to say I bought one on ebay for 500. <br /><br />It looks like it will be cheaper to just replace the stator than buy a test wheel for $356 from the next closest dealer.<br /><br />Owning an OMC/BRP product in NH really can suck. Maybe I should move.
 

Paul Moir

Admiral
Joined
Nov 5, 2002
Messages
6,847
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

maxrules.com and esitest.com (manufacturer) both sell it but for $35. That's a good price. Did winter arrive for you yesterday as well?
 

alden135

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
1,770
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

Winter arrived with 12". Not to cold though.
 

rodbolt

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 1, 2003
Messages
20,066
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

ill agree on the erratic or no spark condition. no agument there, but the capacitor discharge is measured in milliseconds and the voltage across the M terminals is the same as the voltage in the coil primaries. there is little current and a very short duration. not enough to go both ways, it will either arc across the kill circuits or flow through the coil primaries. unless somehow the impedance is matched, I use impedance here due to the fact we are looking at a very rapid rise and fall of the circuit voltage. its amazing how little resistence is required to turn the pack off. I have had to many issues with corroded kill switches, some of them will read 5-8 Kohms and shut off the spark. I have also seen a bad kill switch kill one pack and not the other on twins. I got that one after 3 other techs gave up.<br /> Alden, contact stevens instruments for a set of coil primary terminal extenders, also snap-on sells a nice Kv tester to oberve secondary spark voltage. <br /> but you need to either have it run up on a dyno or the correct test wheel with a known good inductive tach to insure its a motor issue and give a baseline for further testing.<br /> if you suspect a kill circuit issue simply dissconect the black/yellow wire from the pack harness at the pack.<br /> I have seen kill ciruits with high resistance break down the circuit resistance at high speeds and not at lower speeds. I have also seen internal pack faults,usually in the voltage regulating portion, create a high speed loss of spark thats actually rather smooth.<br /> I prefer an analog meter for this type issue personally because it reacts so much faster.<br /> but if its a kill circuit failure or an internal pack problem your DVA readings will reflect it with a decrease in coil primary voltage. once coil primary voltage drops much below about 60V it quits sparking.<br /> its actually amazing how much voltage those charge coils can put out, thats why the pack has an internal regulator, the faster you rotate a set of magnets around a coil of wire the more voltage is generated and the higher the frequency. be careful playing with the blk/yellow wire, its at the same potential or slightly higher than the individual coil primaries, most run around 200 volts. its non lethal but it will make ya jump.<br /> back when we used ign systems that ran all the ign voltage through the keyswitch we had a lot of low current/weak coil primary voltage problems, now on modern systems the ign switch either opens the circuit for the capacitor ground path or completes it. once completed the capacitor will discharge to ground rather than the resistance of the coil primary circuit.<br /> test each stator charge coil leads for shorts to ground, if no shorts to ground are noted test the loaded stator output, it should be above 150 volts. the coil primary voltage should remain within 10 volts of the stator input voltage, the pack does not step up the voltage, whatever the loaded chargecoil voltage input is the output is about the same.<br /> it does not happen often and I have never seen it on single pack motors but the potential for having one bank run at a different timing is there, thats why I say verify the marks and add one for #2 cylinder so timing on both banks can be confirmed.<br /> I hate to keep saying it but if you suspect a kill circuit issure remove the black/yellow wire from the amphenol connector and retest. be careful as there will be no good way to imediatly shut the motor off. if there is an improvement in engine performance then test the switch and harness, if no improvement is noted odds are the problem is elsewhere.
 

alden135

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
1,770
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

Joe, Rodbolt,<br /><br />I suspect that your combined totals of outboard repair experience is at least twice the amount of time I've been alive. <br /><br />This is what I'm going to do:<br /><br />1. The ign switch (as mentioned earlier by me) sticks in "start" so I have to replace it anyway. I'll do that first. It sat in the snow and rain before I bought the boat.<br /><br />2. I'm going to get an appropriate meter for testing the components. If the switch was the problem, I can still use the meter in the future on this, or other motors. <br /><br />3. If the switch isn't it I will go through the test procedures as suggested combined with my manual. ( I've already done the linc/sync and timing)<br /><br />4. I know it's not a real test but when I pulled the flywheel to replace the TB the stator did not show any signs of meltdown. I realize it could still be no good.<br /><br /><br />These problems I have been having have an upside. I am learning a lot that will be handy later. I can't thank you all enough for letting me pick your brains.
 

byacey

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 20, 2005
Messages
443
Re: Need tech explanation, ignition switch

Yep, corrosion in the ignition switch can create leakage between the contacts that would create this problem. I have never seen potting compound become hygroscopic, it's usually an epoxy . There is the possibility of the epoxy cracking though. Follow Rodbolt's advice, he's giving you good information.
 
Top