Re: 1971 9.5hp Evinrude Spring rewind HELP!
You need to pull the rope all the way out until you have the rope knot facing you. Then wedge a pliers handle under the plastic pinion to engage its teeth with the flywheel teeth. Cut the knot off the rope and allow the spool to slowly unwind when you remove the pliers. Place a large flathead screwdriver in the top of the starter shaft and turn counter-clockwise 20 1/2 turns. Then align the rope anchor on the spool so you can see it. Reinsert the end of the rope in the anchor and tie an overhand knot. Be sure the rope is routed thru the grommet on the front motor cover, and around the engine side of the spool. Once your knot is tied, remove the pliers and slowly allow the rope to recoil onto the spool.
I had a heck of a time getting the end of the rope thru the anchor hole, but I finally did. I used a small pick to push it thru. Good luck.