Re: 1985 Sea Horse 5 HP
Gear oil was Ok ... not been sitting half full off water ?
Lubrication of the actual gear shift lever can be a problem although there is IIRC a grease nipple on there.
You should be able to feel some movement of the lever if the problem lies down below but if the lever feels solid then it has probably seized up due to lack of lubrication.
Try freeing oil, and warming of the casting around the lever (pour boiling water on it). If it really is stuck you'll have to take the power head off (and gearcase before that) to sort it out.
Not trying to shift into gear while not running ? If so turn the prop a bit while trying.
Odd model that 5hp not on the brp parts list. I think it is basically one made for the european market ( Is it made in Belgium? ) but pretty much the same as the 6 hp.
Keep an eye on the cooling. My 6 hp has recurring prolems with the grommet at the top of the water tube.