200hp Mariner Overheating

48 OFF

Cadet
Joined
Feb 27, 2008
Messages
6
I've got a 1984 Mariner with an overheating prob. and I apologize in advance for the length of this post.

This motor began to overheat approx. 2 - 3 years after it and the bass boat were purchased new. The buzzer would sound at wot and as soon and as you backed of a little the buzzer would quit. The boat had a new impeller installed every two years since new. This has been a constant and never has an impeller ever come apart.

I brought the boat to a boat mechanic which has done me right in the past and over the next 3-4 years we attempted various fix’s including, lowering the motor on transom, plugging top two intake holes, placing stainless fins over intake holes, rerouting hose from tstats to dump directly out of the cover with 3/8 line from each individual tstat, and replacing impeller pump housing.

In the last 5-6 years the motor has begun to overheat at lower and lower speeds. During the summer months here in Texas it is impossible to even get it on plane with the increase surface water temps.

This lead me to dive back into this project last year and this is what I have done as of late. Removed fins around intake holes, unplugged two top intake holes, raised motor back to original position, rebuilt carbs w/ factory jetting, replaced impeller and housing, replaced plugs but didn't set gap because plug style was flush, replaced poppet valve spring and diaphragm and grommet. Then I cut of a couple coils when problem persisted. This changed nothing if anything it makes it worse.

I also removed power head to replace seal that tube from impeller hosing fits into and removed cleaned and replace water jacket cover above cylinders. The only change that I retained was the straight dump out of the tstats. I did so because they didn't make a difference when we did it and they enable me to closely watch the volume of water coming from t-stats instead of just the pressure as you see with pee hole.

I do not have a pressure gauge or a temp gauge but I did experiment a little the other day with muffs on and this is what I found.

First, with everything together on motor I started and increased throttle until water flow diminished to a trickle from tstats. It is at this point that it usually overheats on lake. This happened at around 12 - 14 hundred rpms. As soon as water flow disappeared I went to idle and approx 8 - 10 seconds later the water began flowing out of t-stats again.

Next, I removed outer cover to poppet valve and replaced bolts with shorter ones. This enables me to watch poppet valve operation because of the now exposed diaphragm. Motor was started and at 12 - 14 hundred rpms water flow again diminished from tstats. At exactly the same time the poppet valve began releasing water. Once again the motor was brought back to idle and approx 10 secs later water began flowing from tstats.

Finally, I removed poppet valve assembly completely and plugged hole using a carved down stopper for transom. I again started motor and increased rpms waiting for water to stop flowing from tstats. It never did. Without the poppet valve the motor ran as it should at least with muffs on.

I have done compression tests on this motor in the past and went ahead and did another one after this little test. 125lbs on every cylinder just like it always does.

There is no corrosion in the water passages that I can see.

This leads me to believe that I need a stronger poppet valve spring. Could this be the problem that has nagged me for over 20 years? Is there any way exhaust gasses could be escaping and pressurizing the water passages causing valve to open.

Any help from you guys would be great. I have almost broke down and bought a new motor several times. I also know that I need a pressure gauge and a temp gauge from reading the other posts. Let me know best brand and place to get if you can.

Thanks for any input at all, even if only to criticize my longer than normal post.
 

hkeiner

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Oct 17, 2006
Messages
1,055
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

The more experienced guys on this forum may have some ideas as to what you may have missed. I don't, but here are my thoughts in case they are any help...

My approach now would be to install the pressure and temperature gauges before doing any more work. The readings on these gauges, at various speeds, will probably provide a good clue and/or narrow down the possible causes of overheating. Of course, this is my opinion because I prefer to troubleshoot problems using test equipment and such, rather than replacing a lot of parts at random or on hunches (educated guesses). You can find suitable gauges for sale on the Iboats Marine Store. I think that any brand would be OK. I choose gauges based upon appearance and price.

Good luck,
 

48 OFF

Cadet
Joined
Feb 27, 2008
Messages
6
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

Appreciate the advice. Was told by the mechanic who was unable to fix this thing that there wasn't a place to mount the sensors. I am curious where you guys mounted your temp sending units and where you plumbed in for the pressure gauge. Need to know if I should purchase special mounts for the temp sensor. I don't see any place by the top clylinders other than the factory sending units. Also any ideas on the overheating problem would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.
 

j_martin

Admiral
Joined
Sep 22, 2006
Messages
7,474
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

The engine probably has a temp gauge sender on it already. There is an overtemp switch on one head, and a temp sender at the same location on the other head. Standard mercury part if it isn't there.

On top of the block, just aft the flywheel is a 3/8" pipe plug. Remove that and install either a sender for an electrical pressure gauge, or a barb for the hose to a mechanical gauge. This would help trememdously in diagnosing the problem.

This engine burns about 3 million BTU/hour in fuel at WOT. Anything wrong in that process can easily cause overheating, such as wrong timing, too lean, etc. A full formal link n sync is in order, as well as plug reading after a kill switch cutoff at the troublesome speeds.

It is possible that the poppit opening too soon will divert too much water from the upper areas of the block. I'd go back to stock and leave it alone if it operates normally.

There are a few cooling mods used on hot rod 2.4's. Look up "cherry 2.4" over at byuboyz.com. T-rex is the grand wizzard of 2.4 mods. He loves to tinker with them, spending little money, and then go buzzing by the big motas turning 10 grand or so.

It sounds to me like your cooling is pretty normal. Go after the lean burn stuff next.

Might be worth the trouble to pop off the exhaust cover and divider. Overheating likely toasted the divider seal anyway, and it gives you a look as some of the small cooling passages that could be blocked. It's 2 gaskets and a strip seal. 'bout a gazillion bolts. Be careful not to strip them.

hope it helps
John
 

hawgherder

Recruit
Joined
Feb 23, 2008
Messages
5
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

I had a 1984 black max that overheated at idle. I fix it by replacing the head gaskets that were improved over the original equip. They were mercury OEM gaskets too. I also used to have a evinrude that overheated at wide open and after years of running below max power I pulled the heads and found scored cylinders. It had good compression also. It did the same thing: throttle back and horn quit sounding. Compression checks on 2 stroke engines are not always a good indicator of engine condition, but are certainly helpful.
 

j_martin

Admiral
Joined
Sep 22, 2006
Messages
7,474
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

Taking off the exhaust cover will give you a pretty good peek at the exhause side of the pistons also. If it's gonna score, that's where it'd be.

hope it helps
John
 

48 OFF

Cadet
Joined
Feb 27, 2008
Messages
6
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

Thanks guys appreciate all the great advice from everone. Talked to a old mechanic who has been workin on and racing these old merc/mariners for a long time. Same advice he gave me is mirrored here. Will start with popit valve and temp/pressure and get back to you. How can I tell which sensor is for the over heat and which one is for the gauge? Also what gauge is compatilbe with the provided senssor. Any further help or ideas will be greatly appreciated.

Thanks
Chris
 

flabum

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 17, 2007
Messages
567
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

Have you replaced the lower water pump housing and gakets. I have seen many boats with this problem and have found blown gaskets and warped lower housings.
 

gss036

Commander
Joined
Jan 18, 2003
Messages
2,914
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

The overheat alarm sensor is nothing more than a compression type cap that pops out when overheated and the resets when it cools down. They use to beinstalled on the starboard head, but will fit either side if it is like my 89 Merc.
 

48 OFF

Cadet
Joined
Feb 27, 2008
Messages
6
Re: 200hp Mariner Overheating

I don't think this motor has heads but I have replaced the water jacket cover gaskets. I have also replaced the entire water pump housing. The sensors are both located on the top of the water jacket covers. They both have a brown wire going to them. I assumed they were both for the buzzer and on off type sensors. Let me know if I am wrong. It would be great if I could use one for the temp gauge.
 
Top