Re: 3 vs 4 blade
I did a similar swap. I have an 18' fiberglass bowrider (crownline). It has the 4.3 MPI and alpha Gen II.
I was using an AL 3 blade 21P with a 14.25" diameter. I went to a 4 blade SS 19P @ 14" diameter.
Swap worked perfectly for me. Much happier with the performance.
The suggestion to go from the 21P to the 19P with this prop was from the seller.
Many prop dealers have a swap program, where you can switch one prop for an identical one of a different pitch. You could see if you have that available, sometimes you just won't know for sure till you run.
The swap program I had was only available for SS props, and you had to return your prop in a certain time frame, undamaged of course.