Re: 7.5hp Gamefisher..........how fast?
using the GPS the speed between the 5 and the 7.5 was only like one mph different
That's the same experience I had, maybe a touch better, but not 50% more power.
I bought a 14' jon boat and tried both of those outboards, both would plane the 1436 jon boat, but nothing impressive. I sold both of them and bought a 7.5 Force (sears) and the 1436 jon boat flies, it will even plane me, another adult and all of our carp, max load, somewhere around 660#. With just me onboard it goes just fine, 20MPH+.
I do agree that it might be a problem with the hull design/size, weight and weight distribution. I used to have the 5HP Force (same as yours) on a Coleman Crawdad and it would plane and go fast, but weight distribution was very important. I sold the Crawdad and bought a WaterTender 9.4, that hull was a pig and wouldn't plane out, 5-7MPH tops. Had it for a year and bought the 1436 jon boat. The same 5 HP outboard would plane the long jon boats, but not the short cathedral hull (tri-hull) boat.
Have you checked to see if the keel of the boat is straight, not hooked or bowed out/down, and the bottom side is straight with no big dents?