Aluminium or Fiberglass?

Ltmcleod

Cadet
Joined
Mar 21, 2010
Messages
11
I'm looking to buy my first boat, I will mostly be bowfishing lakes and rivers along with ducking hunting them too. I will be on the coast occasionally but not as often. What would you got with? Pro's and con's? I'm just not sure which will be best for me, seeing as I have no boat experience. Thanks for the help.
 

Bob_VT

Moderator & Unofficial iBoats Historian
Staff member
Joined
May 19, 2001
Messages
26,065
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

My vote is aluminum ;)
 

Silvertip

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,771
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

It appears you will be trailering nearly 100% of the time. Advantage = aluminum due to weight and less HP needed to move the same size boat, as well as less HP in the tow vehicle and hence better economy. Since you will use this boat for hunting which gets you into some questionable water (stumps, rocks, wing dams etc), advantage again goes to aluminum. Aluminum also requires less maintenance and there is less heartache if one does tag a rock whereas a good thump with a glass boat and you have some relatively painful repairs. If it is beauty you are after, then a glass boat has a little more sex appeal than a tin boat. You can obviously do nearly everything with a glass boat that you can do with an aluminum but mishaps will be a little more of an issue. You will hear all sorts of stories about bad welding or rivets that leak. Having owned many boats over the years with a good mix of glass and aluminum, I do prefer aluminum and I've never had a leaky rivet or a broken weld. Is it possible? Certainly! Is it likely? Very unlikely. Will you have an issue with a glass boat? Probably not? So you see -- there is no right answer. Buy what lights your fire. You haven't mentioned boat size but if you are a serious fisherman, you don't likely want a dual console as the port side console gets in the way and takes up valuable space. There are plenty of center and side console models from nearly every manufacturer. Probably the best smaller boat for fishing for one, two, or three people is a tiller steered boat in the 16 - 17 foot range. And at the other end of the spectrum is a Ranger Bass boat. There are enough makes and models to research it will make your eyes bleed. Have fun -- good hunting.
 

veritas honus

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jun 13, 2010
Messages
1,876
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

A boat for rivers/lakes, especially for duck hunting, will be in shallow water quite often. Aluminum is the way to go if you'll be skimming over rocks and branches all the time. The type of boat you'll want for those purposes, will not be very safe for coastal fishing. For coastal fishing, you'll want a deep Vee hull; which won't serve you well in shallow, rocky water. Look at the different hull types and see what you come up with. Keep the questions coming.
 

Ltmcleod

Cadet
Joined
Mar 21, 2010
Messages
11
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

I'm thinking 16'-19', tiller has been a thought, really would prefer a center console. I want to be able to get up and go if I need too. Thanks for the input
 

NYBo

Admiral
Joined
Oct 23, 2008
Messages
7,107
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

Another vote for aluminum, for all the good reasons already cited.
 

veritas honus

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jun 13, 2010
Messages
1,876
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

Have you given any thought toward a stick steer? It will leave all the room in the boat free. In case your not familiar, a stick steer looks like a throttle. It glides forward and reverse like a throttle. Forward/port, back/starboard, depending upon how it's set up. My Father-in-Law has a 14' jon boat with a 40HP johnson O/B. It's a stick steer, and he loves it... So does my 7 year old son who "drives" Grampa's boat all the time:D. Oh... And by the way... It's aluminum;).
 
Last edited:

Ltmcleod

Cadet
Joined
Mar 21, 2010
Messages
11
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

I actually have been considering a tiller instead of center console. I figured I would have more room and it would be lighter.

I should have been more specific when i said coast. Mostly bay waters and some spanish fishing on the beach.
 

Silvertip

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,771
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

You are definitely not ready to buy a boat. Not ready meaning "research not done!" You really need to spend some time at as many dealers as you have time for. Decide first on boat type (center console, side console, tiller,) then on length and then on manufacturer and model. If you go into this hoping to have a boat twiddle your heart string you will end up with something you really didn't want, can't use effectively, and perhaps spent too much or too little money on. Research, research, research and when you think you are done, research some more. Good Luck.
 

lncoop

Vice Admiral
Joined
Apr 18, 2010
Messages
5,147
Re: Aluminium or Fiberglass?

As usual, Silvertip is right. You need to do some poking around. Look at http://www.seaark.com/ and http://www.xpressboats.com/ for examples of quality welded aluminum boats. There are other good ones as well, but these two will give you a nice representation of what's available and what will best meet your needs. Now, for your intended application, I can't help but think you'd be happy with a 17'-18' semi-V welded aluminum boat with a tiller-steered 50-75 horse. My uncle's duck boat is a 17' Excel http://www.excelboats.net/ with a 50 horse tiller-steer Tohatsu. He had them put a 70 lb thrust Minn Kota on the front deck. I've hunted out of it with him and it is the cats. I think something like that would serve you well.
 
Top