Re: aluminum hull repair
On my little boat (12' aluminum) I used Gorilla Glue where the aluminum on the transom meets the aluminum bottom. Gorilla glue expands once applied, it can creap into the crack and seal it, worked great for me. I would agree that the silicone must be completely removed first.
Do not over apply, if you do remove excess before it sets. Once dried it is like concrete. Also Marine Tex is a great product.