Re: Another prop question
First I should clarify all of my boating and propping experience is with outboard motors, not inboards or I/O's. So I don't really know what your RPM's should be. However, the effects of changing prop pitch and diameter is typically consistent in therory but not consistent from one manufacturer to another, within the same manufacturer, nor one material type to another.
Changing from the 19 to the 21 should put you into the top end of theMax WOT RPM range you provided and eliminate or minimize the chance of over reving the motor. You will loose a little hole shot but I don't think it will be much at all. You should gain a couple MPH top end speed and experience better cruising speed. Going up to a 23 pitch will reduce your hole shot considerably from the 19 pitch but still should keep your motor operating within the MAX WOT RPM range and eliminate the risk of over rev. You'll also get considerably more MPH over the 19 (maybe 5 or 6 MPH) but may experience some porpoising if the 23 doesn't quite get you into the RPM range or in the low end of the range.
For the most consistent result, try to stay within the same brand of and model prop, and approximately the same diameter.
I'm sure others with better knowledge of your rig will have better info.