Some fins are just butt welded to the alum. tube. Others fins have a flange bent first, and that's welded to the tube. With both, it depends on how many times it's already been straightened. Docks can play hell on the spray deflectors/fins, bending them regularly if you aren't careful. After several "straightenings" a butt weld is likely starting to fatigue and crack. Straightened often enough the weld will break. Fins with flanges can usually handle more abuse, but they too will fail eventually.
My point to all that is straightening is usually done while holding your breath and crossing your fingers so nothing cracks (further) or breaks off. I don't think how or what you use to straighten, or how careful you are you stand a good chance of needing a welder when done.
Hammer marks show forever on alum. I would avoid the use of anything but a plastic, rubber or wooden mallet if you must.