Best places to stay in Pine Island, FL

BigJ08

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Sep 18, 2008
Messages
308
Trying to put together an all guys fishing trip down to the Pine Island/Matlacha area. Have done a lot of looking but can't seem to settle on anything. Was wondering if any locals or any others had some suggestions. Looking at a group of about 5-6 guys and staying 4 nights. Any opinions?
 

pine island fred

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
1,144
Re: Best places to stay in Pine Island, FL

Been away for awhile and just saw your post. Give me a day and will come up with something. MATLACHA is nice but it is to far from any open water, look at a map. Best bet is ST. JAMES CITY, clear shot to open water. Off season, place is deserted. Right off the top of my head at this time of night, TARPON LODGE at PINELANDS, north towards BOKILEEA, excellent location. regards FRED
 

pine island fred

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
1,144
Re: Best places to stay in Pine Island, FL

Did some serious research last night right up until closeing time.
First off, MATLACHE, that would be the WATER FRONT, right at the bridge. Nice place, can go out on the bridge fishing with 20 other people at 3 in the morning. Park the boat at your front door. Down side is that you are on the back side, in the middle of the island and you have to cover some ground to get to open water. Also, cant figure out where you would leave your trailer as space is a premium.
I recommended the TARPON LODGE, let me take that back. Nice place, excellent water location but is remote from everything. Resturant is one of those nuveo california cusine places. Only go there when someone else is buying. Meals are all in the presentation on the plate and you have to look back at the menu to figure out what you are eating. Works if you want to spend your evening in a sports coat, sipping your chardonnay, discussing the days fishing. Have a feeling thats not what you are looking for. Soooo
St JAMES CITY, lots of canals, ramps, bars and places to eat. Thats where you want to go. Most recommended at the bar is the GOLDEN PALMS RESORT, 239-283-7378. STEPHANY, owner of the RAGGED AAZ SALOON, mispelled on purpose to get by the web censor chip, says to call DENESE, business is way off and rates are very reasonable. Anyone would be proud to take their family there. Next up is a place called WATERS EDGE, 283-0515, also is a place called TWO FISH INN, 283-4519. All have very good boat dockage on the canal and lots of room to stash your trailer. Any of the above would be good.
Bit of advice, nearest gas station is 7 miles away, so fill up your boat and bring extra gas cans. Sometimes the gas station runs out of gas which can be a dissapointment. Dont think there are any marinas that pump fuel in the area. Once all the evening places close down, come up to FROGGYS and ask for FRED/SANDY, barmaid has our nbr. and buy us a drink. After all, all this research is worth something. Lots of interesting locals, women with sob stories, sad fisherman with broke or sunken boats, everyone looking for a job, you get the picture. regards FRED
 
Top