Confused about my catch...

TBarCYa

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
781
Yesterday I went on my first fishing trip of the season. Catch was a sand shark, two small flatties and the mystery fish. All of which were released.

I was drifting in the Delaware Bay and there were schools of fish at the surface with hundreds of fins above the surface and sometimes even jumping out of the water. There were no gulls following the schools but I didn't think anything of it at the time. Since they appeared fairly aggressive I assumed bluefish and threw whatever I had into the school. Squid strips, live minnows and even a diamond jig but they wouldn't bite. I could feel them running into the lure but nothing would bite. I hooked one on the diamond jig that was on a bass rod with braided line and ended up losing the jig and figured the fish bit it off. At one point I did manage to catch one as I foul hooked it and again I assumed it was a bluefish but the fins were yellow. I haven't fished in a long time so I may have forgotten what a weakfish looks like but the more I look at pictures, the more I think it might have been a weakie.

My question is, does the behavior of swimming in large schools at the surface but not necessarily feeding point towards it being a weakie rather than a blue? The more I think about it the more I want to say it was a weakie but I've heard that they've been hard to catch in this area which has me leaning more towards a blue.
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,339
Re: Confused about my catch...

Did they look like this? :D

bluefish.jpg


Bluefish have yellow fins when young .

In order to catch them in that mode you need to match the hatch. They're most likely chasing "rain" minnows so throwing squid strips, minnows and diamond jigs will get you nowhere as you found out. Had you used a small silver Stingsilver or simular bait you could have filled the boat.

FWIW: Trout are bottom feeders. They are not going to be crashing bait on the surface.
 

TBarCYa

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
781
Re: Confused about my catch...

That's what it looked like. I know I've caught weakies on the bottom before but was thrown off by the coloring. They were out again today but as I'm sure you figured I didn't have any luck. Now that I know I'll make sure to get a couple of those and keep one tied on at all times.

Thanks.
 
Top