Dorman products scare me

68C15

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 15, 2009
Messages
109
first off I must mention that I am a veteran mechanic with over 23 years experience under the hood professionally.

lately I have lost faith in their stuff. they used to be the cat's meow by having things the dealer had but at a great saving and improving on OE designs.

it all started with the coolant elbows for the GM 3800 V6. the O rings were leaking within 3 months. we have replaced so many with them it's scary. now we get them right from GM although they cost about twice. can't take chances with a customer's car.

then we had a set of oil cooler lines on a 2000 Blazer fail with about 7 months and less than 3000 miles. the rubber was cracking and looked worse than a fuel hose exposed to the environment for 30 years. the vehicle lost 4 quarts of oil and the customer saw the wetness on ground as she was walking back to car in parking lot. once again, we replaced with OE at about twice the price but quadruple the confidence.

follow that up with failed wheel studs on a 95 Blazer. we replaced all 10 on the front. I noticed they were severely rusted while I was replacing both front wheel speed sensor/backing plates. I already had the hubs off so I used the shop press to install them. I should note that we use a 4 step process to install wheels so as that we don't have any wheel loss issues. the RF had 4 of the 5 studs just snap while the customer was making a slow left turn. once again, we replaced with OE at a cost to the shop and lost time for me.

is there anything Dorman makes I can trust?
 

NetDoc

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 20, 2011
Messages
517
Re: Dorman products scare me

Dorman plastics have always been suspect, but their steel has been OK. But hey, I've been out of automotive since the turn of the century. I don't miss it! :D
 

mommicked

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 15, 2009
Messages
1,700
Re: Dorman products scare me

I replaced the oilcooler lines on my 98 S10 6+ years ago and was suprised I could not find them at aftermarket stores. I got them at the dealership and they were leaking at the crimped hose connection at less than 2 years:mad: Thanks for the heads up on the defective parts. I'm about to do my front brakes and have heard bad things about certain rotors and brake pad manufacturers also.
 

68C15

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 15, 2009
Messages
109
Re: Dorman products scare me

we use Raybestos brake and chassis parts and have had no problems at all.

about the GM lines leaking, we have them crimped tighter before installation. we use the same crimper as AC lines and do it in-house
 

mommicked

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 15, 2009
Messages
1,700
Re: Dorman products scare me

They should come ready to install for what they cost:mad: I guess it's another way for them to force you to let THEM fix your auto:mad: No offense to the northern guys, but could'nt help but notice a made in Canada sticker on the oil line assembly. This was before the bailout. Why can't parts be made here in the US? Oh, I remember why now:mad: Do you suppose I can get the dealership to re-crimp my leaky hose now? or have them do the next one I might buy if I tell them what I've learned about your procedures?
 

cyclops2

Banned
Joined
Apr 19, 2011
Messages
1,237
Re: Dorman products scare me

Dorman must have a profit minded management team now. The more we sell in less time,the sooner I can order my next larger yacht.
 

kylejb2663

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
177
Re: Dorman products scare me

I am not by any means a professional mechanic but I have been wrenching since I was 13 with my Uncle. I'm now 24 and I have learned a lot.

IMHO lately it seems like when I replace parts on cars, etc... a lot of the products have become cheaper. Even after market parts that I get for my Mustang seem somewhat cheap at times yet they are being sold at a premium price. I use to always use Napa Ultra Premium brakes and I have stopped using them because they seem to wear quick and make LOTS of noise- I have switched back to OEM Parts. Unfortunately, it's expensive but they last.
 
Top