1973 fiberglass boat, gel coat dull, dull. What is best way to make like new? Epoxy paint? Is it possible to spray a new layer of gel coat and make it shiny? I want a new boat for the old price. Any suggestions?? All offers considered.
Pick an inconspicuous spot, like on the transom underneath a swim platform. Start with a 200 grit sandpaper and sand off the oxidized gelcoat over a small area. Go over that with a 1000-1500 grit wet/dry sandpaper (wet). Follow that up with a polishing compound. It should give you the result you're looking for. It's a bit time-consuming, but nothing like trying to repaint or re-gelcoat. Lot's cheaper, too. Good luck. . .
I don't think I would start with 200 grit, way too aggressive. And to go to 1500 (or 2000) from 200 would take forever to work out the scratches that the 200 left behind.
I'd start with a good compounding, and see how that looks. You might be surprised. If not, then go to a wet sand of about 1500 or 1000. Do this in small area to see if it works, or if a more aggressive step is needed.
If you do use a machine (sander, polisher, etc.), be sure you know what you're doing. Gelcoat typically isn't very thick, and you can go right through it without much effort if you do it incorrectly.
My $0.02