Re: Johnson 25hp 1975 prop question
are you sure it is a long shaft?? I bet it is not. Here is a pict of my 1970 short shaft 25 hp. Notice on this type (that don't have through the prop exhaust) there is a water pump pickup above the anti-ventilation plate. Most transoms for short shaft motors are 16", which should put the water line on plane about 1/2 way between the anti-ventilation plate and the little splash deflector plate above it.
Sometimes people measure the distance to the anti-ventilation plate on these motors and are confused that it is something like 18".... but that's because they should be run deeper than newer ones. Don't go by what a previous owner told you... often they don't know what they are talking about.
So, I'm not surprised you needed to trim your transom a bit if it was 17", and you are using a short shaft motor.
Also, it's possible that you're running a prop from an older, larger HP OMC motor. With mine, I got a spare prop that is a 13" pitch, fits on and works, but I'm pretty sure it is off an older 28, 33 or even 40 (?) hp motor. The blades and hub are a bit thicker than the correct prop for this motor. It would get me home, but the 25 hp does not have the power to get to proper WOT rpms. I've been using a 9x9 on mine, but the standard prop (for my motor anyway) was 9x10".
good luck.