Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

Phobos

Cadet
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
9
Hello there everyone. I am a new user to the board but, not necessarily new to boating. A friend and I owned a couple of boats but, it was back in the late 80's maybe early 90's (young and foolish!) and I am sure things have changed.

We had owned a USED 72 Sea Ray cuddy cabin with a 351 V8 and mercury outdrive, and then we upgraded to a USED 1983 or so 23' sun runner cabin cruiser with a 350 v8 and alpha one outdrive. (if my memory serves)

Anyway, we had very little trouble with the i/o drive or engines. We left the boats in the water (Small fresh water lakes) here in IL and outside of having to clean the green slime off the outside of the boat and maybe replace the zinc pieces ever year, the I/O's were pretty reliable. Granted we had the 72 Sea ray for only 1 season. It was our starter boat but we kept the sun runner for about 5 to 7 years.

Anyway... looking to get a small USED boat for a lake we have a vacation home on in Wisconsin. Probably a bow rider. It's about 180 acres of water and averages 12 feet deep but does go as deep as 30 feet in places. I plan on putting the boat in the water in the spring and then taking it out in the fall. I plan on storing it in the garage during the off-season. When docked, I plan on using one of those boat lifts that hoists the boat up and out of the water. I realize there is maintenance but I don't want to spend all summer screwing around with the boat.

When I say small, I'm thinking 17 to 19 feet. I plan on using it for pulling an inner tube type thing and probably a single water skier. My family is my wife and me and my 12 year old daughter. I would expect to have a few others on the boat from time to time but I think I only need to carry 6 or 7 passengers at the most. I don't plan on being speed racer on the lake. From past experience I know that 15 to 20 mph for a tube is more than enough. I don't think I 'll need to go more than 45 mph. I have seen 2 cycle jet ski's on my lake so I don't think there are 2 stroke limitations. (I heard that some lakes only allow 4 cycle engines).

Like I stated, I have not had a boat for about 20 years and I am sure things are different now in some aspects. I guess I had 3 questions.

1) What are your thoughts on the engine system? Outboard or I/O or jet drive?? I have read some posts about the pros and cons of IO and outboards but many seemed to have to do with salt water which does not apply to me. I have not seen much on jet drives. I am fairly good with engines (replaced radiators and starters and so on in cars) but I know how cramped it can be in those engine compartments. I don't know anything about an outboard or a jet system.

2) For I/o drives, my last 2 boats were V8's. I don't remember seeing any 4 cylinder engines back then but now it seems there are lots of 4 bangers out there. Not sure if they have enough power (135 HP for the 3,0 liter engines). I have seen some 6 cylinders too.

3) As I stated, I plan on buying used boat. I have been looking around and think boats from 2003 to 2012 would be too expensive, and those from before 1995 may be just too old and have too many issues. So, my target age is 1996 to maybe 2002, and my price range is probably from 4k to 9k but the prices seem to vary widely here in Northern IL. I see the usual names like Sea Ray, Bayliner, Donzi, Wellcraft, and so on. If I remember right Bayliners were sort of low end there in the 80's when AMF owned them. I see some VOLVO drives and many Mercruisers. I see very few OMC's for sale but I think OMC went out of business. I also see new names like SeaDoo and Yamaha jet boats and not sure about the quality of some of these. Is there anything I need to look out for or any known LEMONS from that era.

Thank you in advance.
 

agallant80

Commander
Joined
Oct 25, 2010
Messages
2,328
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

1. I think its a matter of preference, though I perfer the I/O setup.
2. the 4.3MPI which I had in my last boat made 220HP and it pushed a 21 foot bow rider along at 55mph.
3. Its more about condition and how well it was taken care of rather than who made it. Stay away anything that says OMC, parts are hard to find. I would be leaning twards fuel injected over a carb.

Good luck. lots of people will be chiming in with lots of different thoughts.
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,082
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

Hello there everyone. I am a new user to the board but, not necessarily new to boating. A friend and I owned a couple of boats but, it was back in the late 80's maybe early 90's (young and foolish!) and I am sure things have changed.

We had owned a USED 72 Sea Ray cuddy cabin with a 351 V8 and mercury outdrive, and then we upgraded to a USED 1983 or so 23' sun runner cabin cruiser with a 350 v8 and alpha one outdrive. (if my memory serves)

Anyway, we had very little trouble with the i/o drive or engines. We left the boats in the water (Small fresh water lakes) here in IL and outside of having to clean the green slime off the outside of the boat and maybe replace the zinc pieces ever year, the I/O's were pretty reliable. Granted we had the 72 Sea ray for only 1 season. It was our starter boat but we kept the sun runner for about 5 to 7 years.

Anyway... looking to get a small USED boat for a lake we have a vacation home on in Wisconsin. Probably a bow rider. It's about 180 acres of water and averages 12 feet deep but does go as deep as 30 feet in places. I plan on putting the boat in the water in the spring and then taking it out in the fall. I plan on storing it in the garage during the off-season. When docked, I plan on using one of those boat lifts that hoists the boat up and out of the water. I realize there is maintenance but I don't want to spend all summer screwing around with the boat.

When I say small, I'm thinking 17 to 19 feet. I plan on using it for pulling an inner tube type thing and probably a single water skier. My family is my wife and me and my 12 year old daughter. I would expect to have a few others on the boat from time to time but I think I only need to carry 6 or 7 passengers at the most. I don't plan on being speed racer on the lake. From past experience I know that 15 to 20 mph for a tube is more than enough. I don't think I 'll need to go more than 45 mph. I have seen 2 cycle jet ski's on my lake so I don't think there are 2 stroke limitations. (I heard that some lakes only allow 4 cycle engines).

Like I stated, I have not had a boat for about 20 years and I am sure things are different now in some aspects. I guess I had 3 questions.

1) What are your thoughts on the engine system? Outboard or I/O or jet drive?? I have read some posts about the pros and cons of IO and outboards but many seemed to have to do with salt water which does not apply to me. I have not seen much on jet drives. I am fairly good with engines (replaced radiators and starters and so on in cars) but I know how cramped it can be in those engine compartments. I don't know anything about an outboard or a jet system.

2) For I/o drives, my last 2 boats were V8's. I don't remember seeing any 4 cylinder engines back then but now it seems there are lots of 4 bangers out there. Not sure if they have enough power (135 HP for the 3,0 liter engines). I have seen some 6 cylinders too.

3) As I stated, I plan on buying used boat. I have been looking around and think boats from 2003 to 2012 would be too expensive, and those from before 1995 may be just too old and have too many issues. So, my target age is 1996 to maybe 2002, and my price range is probably from 4k to 9k but the prices seem to vary widely here in Northern IL. I see the usual names like Sea Ray, Bayliner, Donzi, Wellcraft, and so on. If I remember right Bayliners were sort of low end there in the 80's when AMF owned them. I see some VOLVO drives and many Mercruisers. I see very few OMC's for sale but I think OMC went out of business. I also see new names like SeaDoo and Yamaha jet boats and not sure about the quality of some of these. Is there anything I need to look out for or any known LEMONS from that era.

Thank you in advance.

Ayuh,.... Welcome Aboard,.... I like I/Os,...

I'd think a Merc 3.0l, 'n the right prop will give ya the boat ya want in that length,...
 

crabby captain john

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
1,823
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

In your situation I'd prefer an I/O, in mine they would not hold up well. You will need more than 17' as I have never seen one to hold "6 or 7 people" not even considering fuel and equipment. I have a 21' boat. The capacity plate states 9 people, that would not be a comfortable ride. Condition and care mean more than name. Of those you mentioned I'd cross off Bayliner as their reputation in the 80s has not improved in over 2 decades. Forget a 4 banger~~
 

GA_Boater

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
May 24, 2011
Messages
49,038
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

On a 180 acre lake, a bowrider with an outboard sounds like the best choice to me. It's just a motor standing on end, from the crankshaft snout down it's just like an I/O without the 90 degree bend in the middle. Newer 4 strokes and two strokes are very reliable and sip gas. I'm just saying to look at some outboard models.
 

JASinIL2006

Vice Admiral
Joined
Feb 10, 2012
Messages
5,713
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

We boat every summer on a small lake in Canada where we have a cabin. Everybody has a small aluminum boat with an outboard (usually about 10 hp). Several of us also have runabouts that are mainly used to pull skiers or kids on a tube. At our lake, a lot of those boats are outboards. Ours is an I/O, but with a decent-size engine (350 Mag). On a small, semi-remote lake, the noise difference between an OB and I/O is substantial. We've actually had people who don't know us - other than by having seen us pulling kids with our boat - who have asked us how our boat is so quiet. I know many of our neighbors appreciate it. (Not that you'd want to base your boat buying on that, but it is something to think about.)
 

Phobos

Cadet
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
9
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

I would stick with an I/O in your area as well. Here is one that may be close to you, and worth a look I think.

1998 Monterey 19 Montura bowrider, 5.0L V8, very nice shape w/ trailer

Thanks for the info and the link!! :joyous: I had been looking at CL on and off and yes, that boat is pretty close to where I live. Wow, looks BIG in the pictures. Just 19 feet? I see it has a double axle trailer too, not just a single.
 

Phobos

Cadet
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
9
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

Yeah, I guess noise could be an issue. It's a pretty quiet area and I don't want to be THAT GUY!!!! About half the boats on the lake are pontoon boats. All seem to just glide by quietly and slowly. Then maybe another 15% are jetski's and the other 35% evenly split between outboard and I/O 16 to 22 footers. Nothing really big.
 

oldjeep

Admiral
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
6,455
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

Thanks for the info and the link!! :joyous: I had been looking at CL on and off and yes, that boat is pretty close to where I live. Wow, looks BIG in the pictures. Just 19 feet? I see it has a double axle trailer too, not just a single.

Looks bigger than a 19 to me too.

Edit: Maybe it is just the shape of it - the inside picture looks the same dimensions as my 19, but the one on the trailer just makes it look long.
 
Last edited:

Slip Away

Lieutenant
Joined
May 11, 2010
Messages
1,431
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

It's not bigger. It's a 19'6" Monterey Montura just like the add says. Here is an old 196 Monty thread.
http://forums.iboats.com/boat-topic...lease-1997-monterey-montura-196-a-345017.html

I have seen this boat on CL before I think, from a private seller. Ask the dealer if the motor is original, or if it was replaced earlier this year like the one I am thinking of. If it was, ask for documentation of the engine rebuild/replacement. If it looks as good in person as it does in the add, it's one heck of a nice boat for the money. It's a 55 mph boat all day at only about 2800lbs. dry.
 
Last edited:

TheAviator

Cadet
Joined
Oct 11, 2013
Messages
19
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

I have just posted a similar thread, got some good and similar advice you may check it out. I am obviously far from an expert, but I will say one thing, although the Yamaha boats are probably out of both our price range as far as what we are looking to spend presently, from the research I've done, they look like awesome boats. I know one local guy poo poo them because if the engine stops, you have no control over them. But I know yamaha and the are an excellent top notch company with every product they make. Even their pianos are the best mass manufactured pianos on the market. I will most likely eventually get a Yamaha boat, not now, but they look great to me. I also love the jet motor and the ability to cruise right up on the bank of islands. The lay outs in them are great too. Now I'm talking about their larger ski boats, not the really small boats they have made, not familiar with those, but I think their drives are the same.
 

greenbush future

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Messages
1,814
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

I have just posted a similar thread, got some good and similar advice you may check it out. I am obviously far from an expert, but I will say one thing, although the Yamaha boats are probably out of both our price range as far as what we are looking to spend presently, from the research I've done, they look like awesome boats. I know one local guy poo poo them because if the engine stops, you have no control over them. But I know yamaha and the are an excellent top notch company with every product they make. Even their pianos are the best mass manufactured pianos on the market. I will most likely eventually get a Yamaha boat, not now, but they look great to me. I also love the jet motor and the ability to cruise right up on the bank of islands. The lay outs in them are great too. Now I'm talking about their larger ski boats, not the really small boats they have made, not familiar with those, but I think their drives are the same.

Jet boats have some serious drawbacks for pleasure boat use, it would be the last thing I would consider if I planned to tube or water ski. And if you have any chop on your lake, you should expect a bit of a jerky ride as the water intake pops in and out of the water. After reading about your intended use, I would think a nice outboard or I/O would be just fine for your needs. The jet boat.....not even close! I love Yamies too, but if you plan to spend that much on a pleasure boat, then make sure you at least get a test ride on the Yamie before you spend. I think you will be much happier with an outboard!! Jet boats to me at least have a very very limited area they will perform well in. There is s reason you don't see many of them around!!
 

TheAviator

Cadet
Joined
Oct 11, 2013
Messages
19
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

Jet boats have some serious drawbacks for pleasure boat use, it would be the last thing I would consider if I planned to tube or water ski. And if you have any chop on your lake, you should expect a bit of a jerky ride as the water intake pops in and out of the water. After reading about your intended use, I would think a nice outboard or I/O would be just fine for your needs. The jet boat.....not even close! I love Yamies too, but if you plan to spend that much on a pleasure boat, then make sure you at least get a test ride on the Yamie before you spend. I think you will be much happier with an outboard!! Jet boats to me at least have a very very limited area they will perform well in. There is s reason you don't see many of them around!!

Yes I do see your point. No worries, I was no where close to getting a Yamaha boat at present anyway, I have a I/O on my horizon at present. I just meant possibly down the road, but I do see the drawbacks.
 

airshot

Vice Admiral
Joined
Jul 22, 2008
Messages
5,365
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

In my opinion with your price range I would look seriously at an aluminium boat. With the years you are looking at, rotten stringers and transoms are really going to be a problem. With an alum boat the worst case is a pc of plywood on the transom that is relatively easy to replace. Also need a lot less motor to make it go. Only had one glass boat in my 50 yrs of boating and I will never go back to glass.
 

Phobos

Cadet
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
9
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

So....... what happened :confused:


No purchase yet. Still looking around. I did see a nice 2003 4 winns 17 foot boat with a 115 hp outboard but the guys price was $13k. His ad says he was negotiable but the NADA value was like $6k. For a great condition boat with low hours I'd pay over the NADA value but not that much over. I think the NADA site said the suggested retail price when NEW was $18k.

A jet boats is out since it seems that maneuverability is limited when you are going slow. I want something my wife can drive and dock. One quick look at the dents in her car and you can see she needs all the help she can get.

I see some Sea Doo challengers for sale but every one has a engine problem of one sort or another. This one has a bad ignition module on one engine and that one has a dead battery so the engine does not start and this other one here has a bad starter switch so it can be started and demonstrated.

So it's down to a I/O or an outboard. I am leaning towards the outboard but will do a V6 i/o if the opportunity arises. I think the 135 HP 4 bangers would be a bit underpowered and I surely don't need a V8. I am also trying to keep the overall weight down and I think the outboard would weigh less. I have determined that I'm looking between 17 and 19 feet.

But, I need to get the PIER thing nailed down before I drop the hammer on buying a boat. I have had to check with the city, the lake assn, the state of WI, and the county. The state has this Pier Primer document that lays out all the specifics for a pier and what counts as a pier that needs a state permit and inspection and what does not. It also lists out what is or is not allowed.

Luckily the county has no specifics and neither does the lake association. The city is sending me some permit thing that she says is used mainly for keeping on record who has what pier, and I am looking over the Pier Primier and other Wisconsin DNR documents to design my pier so as to not need a permit.

I want to get the Pier thing all set before I drop $9k or whatever on a boat.
 

limitout

Banned
Joined
Oct 1, 2013
Messages
543
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

I think the NADA site said the suggested retail price when NEW was $18k.

the value of a boat is based on the price it would cost to buy that same boat new today so 13k is a fair price and the NADA prices are a joke, they are no where near accurate because they are based solely on the price it cost during the year it was made then they depreciate it. that is NOT what a fair value is on a boat. price what that rig costs brand new today then subtract the nada price for it when it was new and then add that number to what nada says its supposed to be worth and you will have a reasonable ballpark figure of fair market value.

after that condition is everything, average condition is at that price and if its in better then average shape the value goes up.

for the most part nada is useless to value boats but it can give you a ball park idea of the price range that it should be close to as long as you add the increased value of replacement cost to those numbers
 

izoomie

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Oct 16, 2009
Messages
274
Re: Looking to buy a boat - looking for advice

Definitely get fuel injection if you can afford it. The easy starts are well worth it. Carbs can work well if they are newly cleaned and adjusted but you'll have to spend some money on that so conciser spending it on the injection first.
 
Top