Merc SKI Inboard 5.7 260 - Milky Oil

skiNut

Recruit
Joined
Aug 5, 2010
Messages
3
I'm trying to help out the new owner of my old ski boat. I owned the boat for 3 years, a 1989 with the Mercury Inboard Ski package engine 5.7L 260hp. When I got the boat 3-years ago, it ran rough, and I found a bunch of water in the fuel. Drained the water, replaced all the fuel filters/water separator, fuel lines, still ran rough. Had the carb re-built, only ran rough after warming up. Found that it had the wrong coil on it. New coil, has run PERFECT for 3 years.

Buddies lost interest so we sold the boat this spring. I tuned the boat up, de-winterized it, and put it in the water, no problems. Skiied with it a couple of mornings, no problem. The new owners wanted a test ride/ski, drove the boat up to their marina (20 minute ride), picked them up, skiied a couple of times (probably 1/2 hour on the boat), cruised back to my marina, no problems. Sold the boat with "As-Is" on the receipt. They picked the boat up cruised it back to their marina, everyone was happy.

A month later I get a call, boat won't run right. They had run the tank of gas out, filled up on the water at a marina known as having the lowest priced fuel in town, and now it won't start/run right. Sounded to me like bad gas, but they wouldn't hear of it. We had had some really bad rain, and I said that it could also be moisture in the distributor cap. They put a new distributor cap on it, same problem. A couple of days later I get another call. They had to put a new battery in it because the battery was bad, then they had to replace the starter because the starter was bad, and in the process they found teeth missing off the flywheel, so they pulled the engine and put a new flywheel on it. All of this implying that I had done something to provoke this. Now, I have cranked that boat hundreds of times, especially in the spring when de-winterizing, getting full revolutions of the engine, and never once heard it skip, or the bendix wing, like there was teeth off the flywheel.

Yesterday I get a call that now the engine has milky oil, and 4 spark plugs had water in the cylinder. I guess with all the cranking, again if it was bad gas, all the un-combusted fuel could have gone up into the exhaust risers, then just ran back down into the cylinders, past the rings, and into the crank case, but it would have had to be a ton of bad fuel. Now, they did ruin a starter and battery cranking it without firing the engine, so maybe??

The bigger issue to me, is the boat ran perfect when I sold it. They ran it for a couple of weeks, now they are back on my door step implying that I sold them a bad boat. I have been trying to help them out, but I don't like the way this is headed, and would be open to suggestions from the group.

Thank you,
Mike
 

sethjon

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jun 8, 2010
Messages
692
Re: Merc SKI Inboard 5.7 260 - Milky Oil

I'm trying to help out the new owner of my old ski boat. I owned the boat for 3 years, a 1989 with the Mercury Inboard Ski package engine 5.7L 260hp. When I got the boat 3-years ago, it ran rough, and I found a bunch of water in the fuel. Drained the water, replaced all the fuel filters/water separator, fuel lines, still ran rough. Had the carb re-built, only ran rough after warming up. Found that it had the wrong coil on it. New coil, has run PERFECT for 3 years.

Buddies lost interest so we sold the boat this spring. I tuned the boat up, de-winterized it, and put it in the water, no problems. Skiied with it a couple of mornings, no problem. The new owners wanted a test ride/ski, drove the boat up to their marina (20 minute ride), picked them up, skiied a couple of times (probably 1/2 hour on the boat), cruised back to my marina, no problems. Sold the boat with "As-Is" on the receipt. They picked the boat up cruised it back to their marina, everyone was happy.

A month later I get a call, boat won't run right. They had run the tank of gas out, filled up on the water at a marina known as having the lowest priced fuel in town, and now it won't start/run right. Sounded to me like bad gas, but they wouldn't hear of it. We had had some really bad rain, and I said that it could also be moisture in the distributor cap. They put a new distributor cap on it, same problem. A couple of days later I get another call. They had to put a new battery in it because the battery was bad, then they had to replace the starter because the starter was bad, and in the process they found teeth missing off the flywheel, so they pulled the engine and put a new flywheel on it. All of this implying that I had done something to provoke this. Now, I have cranked that boat hundreds of times, especially in the spring when de-winterizing, getting full revolutions of the engine, and never once heard it skip, or the bendix wing, like there was teeth off the flywheel.

Yesterday I get a call that now the engine has milky oil, and 4 spark plugs had water in the cylinder. I guess with all the cranking, again if it was bad gas, all the un-combusted fuel could have gone up into the exhaust risers, then just ran back down into the cylinders, past the rings, and into the crank case, but it would have had to be a ton of bad fuel. Now, they did ruin a starter and battery cranking it without firing the engine, so maybe??

The bigger issue to me, is the boat ran perfect when I sold it. They ran it for a couple of weeks, now they are back on my door step implying that I sold them a bad boat. I have been trying to help them out, but I don't like the way this is headed, and would be open to suggestions from the group.

Thank you,
Mike

If all you say is accurate, sounds like you're being a nice guy. The boat is old and its always buyer beware. You did take them out before the purchase so even if there was a problem they should have had someone qualified to go on the ride. At this point you should tell them you've gone beyond being nice and they have to fix it or sell it.
 

JustJason

Vice Admiral
Joined
Aug 27, 2007
Messages
5,321
Re: Merc SKI Inboard 5.7 260 - Milky Oil

as is, is as is. At this point i would stop being the nice guy and tell them tough tookie. You don't want to get yourself any deeper into this thing incase they try to sue you or something.

They could have hired a mechanic to go through the boat. With any problems with a boat, there's a lot of wild azz guessing as to what could be the problem and what caused the problem, but it usually takes some investigating to pinpoint it.

Alot can happen in the month they owned it, and probably did. And some people out there will stone cold lie to your face especially when money is on the table. Wash your hands of it and walk away, it's their problem now. It was their choice to buy a 21 year old engine. I would stop talking their calls.
 
Top