Re: Newbie questions....come on you know you love them!
a general reply to a general question: 12 gallons is plenty for a 25 2 stroke; should be better for a 4 stroke? If it makes you feel better, carry a 1 gallon "reserve" can--that's what we do with unreliable fuel guages.
Speaking of fuel gauges, never rely on them. I have a 17' Key West with a 17 gallon tank (70 hp). Because the tank is so flat, the gauge can't swing enough to be accurate. I am "full" until I have a quarter, "half" with an eighth. So I just use it like the warning light on a car dash board. Therefore, if you hav an in-hull tank, in the process of learning your boat, you need to run it down to empty. As you fill it, see what it registers with each 3 gallons (quarter).
You may find the 25 is underpowered and want to look for the opportunity to upgrade. Should be no trouble selling 25 while it's in good shape; it's a popular motor. What does your rating plate say?
Is yours the "bay boat" design or the deep V? If it's the former, it's a great shallow water and inshore boat; gets a little wet in the chop but still safe--just trim up the bow.
Welcome to I boats