Outboard vs I/O

fishthebay

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Aug 17, 2001
Messages
180
Hello everyone.<br /><br />I may be in the market for a new boat this fall. Living near the beach, prices drop significantly. <br /><br />My question is do you guys recommend an Outboard or I/O setup?<br /><br />I currently have an outboard and since I am no expert it seems to me if the motor every really fails (not worth fixing) wouldn't it be easier to just back down the ramp and unloosen the motor bolts and let it go to the bottom for a new fish home and then replace it?<br /><br />I/O seems a bit more complex if something really went wrong and pulling an engine would cost a bundle.<br /><br />Any opinions?
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: Outboard vs I/O

Hey, Fish'. You have three choices: I/O, 2 stroke outboard or 4 stroke outboard.<br /><br />If the budget can handle it I think a 4 stroke outboard is the runaway winner.<br /><br />Red sky at night. . .<br />JB :)
 

Dhadley

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 4, 2001
Messages
16,978
Re: Outboard vs I/O

Hey guys, a very interesting article on this subject is in this months Hot Boat magazine.<br /><br />D
 

SS MAYFLOAT

Admiral
Joined
May 17, 2001
Messages
6,372
Re: Outboard vs I/O

I feel it has alot to do with what type of boating that you do. I prefer the quietness of I/O. Being mechanically inclined, I tend to feel safer with an I/O knowing that I can usually repair an engine similar to that of an auto. I have never used a 4 stroke outboard yet, and I say yet because as long as I'm alive, I will always be buying and selling boats until I can't no more. Comparing I/O to a 2 stroke outboard, now I would go with the I/O for the fuel ecomony. But I understand that now the 4 strokes are up there with the I/O's as far as quietness, fuel consumption and performance. It is also true with a outboard, it frees up alot of deck space, but then my buddies and myself like using the motor cover for a nice comfortable place to sit when fishing.
 

my new fishmaster

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 11, 2001
Messages
256
Re: Outboard vs I/O

Well I love alum boats first off and think the outboards are the only way to go. I would consider a used boat as the economy is slowing down and you can find some good deals. Found a Grady White with dual Yammies for sale in my area for a great price.
 

Beernutz

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 14, 2001
Messages
287
Re: Outboard vs I/O

I'm an offshore fisherman, and I always worry about that big hole below the waterline in the transom surrounded only by a rubber bellows. Looks like it could be a pretty quick trip to the bottom.<br /><br />I like 2-stroke outboards for their simplicity. Way less moving parts than 4-strokes to wear and fail. Gotta be cheaper to rebuild, too. I'll wait a little longer for them to prove their case. Of course, I feel the same way about fuel injected 2-strokes. They also have a ways to go, before I can accept them as a reliable option.<br /><br />With an I/O, you will be replacing expensive parts at intervals, but will most likely never change the entire propulsion unit. When an outboard starts giving up on you, four bolts and some minor rigging will give you a whole new lease on life. <br /><br />As you mentioned, most I/O's use automotive engines. That can be a curse, as well as a blessing, particularly if you will be using it in saltwater. The only one I know of that was designed strictly for marine use was the Mercruiser 470/485, but even that one uses a 460 ci Lincoln head, and I think the pistons as well. The marine environment is far more hostile than the highways. An outboard, from the drawing board to the transom, is designed for the job. Also, there is one less direction change in the driveline when you're going straight...more if you're turning. As a result, you have no universal joints or gimbal bearings to worry about in the outboard.<br /><br />I've been both ways over the years, and as you can see have become very biased toward outboards. But both have their advantages, I guess, so it depends entirely on your preference and how you plan to use the rig.<br /><br />Anybody else?
 

dadohead

Recruit
Joined
Sep 26, 2001
Messages
2
Re: Outboard vs I/O

Help! I have an old OMC Stern Drive setup. (1974) I am having a problem with the remote throttle. It will go up to full throttle with no problem and run well. When it is time to drop the throttle there seems to be a dead spot that jumps the thing into neutral. I am wondering if any out there knows why and if you think it is a new control that is needed or is it a gear problem. Once I get beyond the "dead spot" she returns to gear!
 

manowar

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jul 9, 2001
Messages
124
Re: Outboard vs I/O

well that stuff in your reply to flush salt water do you have a name for it thats something id like to try also I think a IO or OB is a preference of what the boats used for and I have 1999 Trophy Bayliner for sale with a 1999 Force fresly rebuilt and back to factory specs and running smooth
 
Top