Re: prop selection
If you are turning 5500 RPM's now with the 13 pitch, you'll be wasting your time and energy with the 17 pitch. You'll have very slow hole shot and slower top speed because the RPM's will not be up where they should be.
The boat probably was originally equipped with the 17 pitch which the owner found did not work well. The 13 pitch worked better but because the boat is smaller, the 11 pitch should be used when you have a full load of people in the boat or pulling a skiier. Although I am assuming all three props are in good condition without excessive knicks in the blades.