SS prop- harder on lower unit?

MushCreek

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 20, 2009
Messages
150
I have an '83 35 hp Johnson, and I'm rebuilding the lower unit for the second time. The previous owner had it rebuilt once, and said it was popping out of gear again, so it would need doing. It didn't look that bad to me, but I resurfaced the clutch faces just in case. Since the motor wasn't used all that much, I can only think of 2 things- either the linkage was adjusted wrong, or the SS prop is beating it up. Back in the old days, old timers insisted that SS props were harder on the lower units because of the greater weight. Makes sense, but I've never had it proven or disproven. I did notice that in '84, they went over to a 3 lobe clutch, which tells me the older design was weak. Would I be wise to get an aluminum prop in the interest of saving the LU, or is it something else? Obviously, I'll set up the linkage properly.
 
D

DJ

Guest
Re: SS prop- harder on lower unit?

Short answer-NO!.

What tears up L/U's is EASING them into gear. Make sure shifts are swift and sure.
 

ezeke

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 19, 2003
Messages
12,532
Re: SS prop- harder on lower unit?

Stainless steel propellers are stronger and flex less in use, giving them an advantage over aluminum. They are heavier and that is more of a problem if your engine is idling too fast as you shift into gear. Or, if you tend to shift quickly from forward to reverse or from reverse to forward. It's not good to do that with any propeller but it is definitely worse with a heavier propeller.
 
D

DJ

Guest
Re: SS prop- harder on lower unit?

Stainless steel propellers are stronger and flex less in use, giving them an advantage over aluminum. They are heavier and that is more of a problem if your engine is idling too fast as you shift into gear. Or, if you tend to shift quickly from forward to reverse or from reverse to forward. It's not good to do that with any propeller but it is definitely worse with a heavier propeller.

Ezeke, Pardon me if I'm misreading your note.

It is GOOD to shift quickly (do not EASE into gear) when going from nuetral. I see your point in going from reverse to forward, or visa versa. I agree, you must allow for the prop to stop spinning.
 

MushCreek

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 20, 2009
Messages
150
Re: SS prop- harder on lower unit?

I'll have to quiz the PO (he's a friend) about his shifting technique. Knowing him, I could picture him 'babying' it into gear (not good) I like the old 2 stick controls; it seems you could put them into gear more crisply without inadvertently giving it throttle. Any thoughts on whether that particular L/U is weak? I don't see too many used for sale- which means they either died young, or they're all still on the water. I know the powerhead is a good design, and ideal for the 13' Whaler I have it on.
 

F_R

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Re: SS prop- harder on lower unit?

Well, my '84 is doing just fine with a SST prop that has been on it since day one. I know, not smart to brag, but....
 
Top