If your replacing the deck in an aluminum Crestliner then the spar varnish would work fine, lot's of us use it.
Ned you could always google the spar we're using. Here is what I use http://www.minwax.com/wood-products/...-spar-urethane
Hope that helps you 'understand' why spar is a 'sealant'. I agree paint is a great choice for sealing just about any material and I usually do both spar and paint on things like transom wood.
Spar can even be exposed to the light of day and not fail like epoxy resin which has to be covered with something so UV doesn't ruin
Epoxy is by far the best, the other products used aren't even close. Paints, spar varnish and other blends are short term at best, they don't start out that water resistant and get worse quickly, so they need to be reapplied frequently to be of much value.
The OP wanted some advice on using Spar from members that have used it before, everyone is entitled to their own opinions but it should be weighed against those who haven't any experience or any builds in their sig line.
As far as penetration into the plywood goes, nothing gets past the first layer of glue. I've cut holes in ply treated with spar and it's penetrated down to the first glue layer.
I would be interested in hearing how "spar varnish" became so popular here as a 'wood sealent'. When I want to apply a protective 'sealent' to wood in a non-visual area my choice would pretty much always be paint. The higher solids content will build faster and provide more abrasion resistance. As for which one 'soaks in more', try stripping both paint and varnish off a surface and find out which one sticks in the grain more.
Just because it is clear, like epoxy, doesn't mean it is more like epoxy than paint.
(I definately agree epoxy is #1, but comes with a price tag.)
I have never understood the recommendation. .. Just wondering.
If I just use the minwax helmsman spar urethane how long would it last? A couple months, a couple years?
So you're saying to just use paint? What kind?
If I just use the minwax helmsman spar urethane how long would it last? A couple months, a couple years?
I knew this would happen, confusing comments from people who have never used either product.
How old is your boat? I'm assuming it's an aluminum Crestliner made in 1987. So the untreated factory deck is needing replaced after 30 years of use and I'm sure some abuse.
Just to add perspective there was no magical epoxy resin or worthless spar on the decking to seal it from the factory in 1987 and it lasted for decades. So anything you do to seal the wood will be better than it was new and last a very long time if you cover it up and not allow the elements to ravage the interior.
On a side note have you checked the transom wood for any signs of decay?
Are you going to put something like carpet over it, and will it be stored indoors or out?