Re: What size prop should I use
Currently I have a 15" with a 15" pitch aluminum 3 blade prop. My top speed is about 32 MPH, not sure about RPM's.
You need to know what your RPM's are before you make any adjustments.
You stated in your first post that you wanted the bes "performance". Well, what are you doing with this boat. Are you looking for top speed performance or are you looking for hole shot performance?
That being said, I have an 18' Maxum with the same motor and use a 4 blade 14x20p prop. I get a 4700RPM WOT @ about 41 MPH, with 3 adults and a cooler of drinks. Hole shot is pretty decent but I'm adding smart tabs as well.
IMO, the key here is knowing what your RPM's are. The recommended WOT RPM's for MY motor is 4400-4800 RPM's. I had a 14.25x21p prop that sucked out of the hole but had a top speed of 43MPH's @ 4600 RPM's.
I would imagine that your RPM's @ WOT with a 15x15p prop is overrevving the engine but you're probably out of the hole like a bat out of hell.
LONG POST SHORT-know your RPM's first. Make a decision afterwards

.