which model fishfinder?! help!

870 Expressmag

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 7, 2011
Messages
154
I need a new fishfinder. I thought this would be easy, NOT! I have a 15ft aluminum Meyers with 18hp tiller evinrude. Nothing fancy by any means. MY current finder is a humminbird wideeye and last year it started making a clicking noise and randomely shutting off on me. Since this finder came with the boat when i bought it last spring i have no history on it and dont know how old it is. But when i could see bottom in 3ft of water and it would jump and say we were in 14 then 27 ft, i knew something was wrong. Anyways, all of my fishing is on small inland lakes. depths reaching 50-60 ft is about the deepest. 3-30 ft more the normal. we fish mostly panfish but occasionally try walleye, catfish, bass, etc. I dont need anything fancy and my budget has me around 300 or less. I cant decide on the DI or regular 2d. the models i was looking at and considering were the lowrance elite 4x, elite 4x dsi, and elite 4. only reason i would like/want the gps of the elite 4 is for marking structure or hotspots in the water, as i researched the software available for these finders and the lakes i fish dont have any extra data so it would be a waste of money for that. but mainly i couldn;t decide between dsi and regular 2d sonar. dsi LOOKS cool but to me doesnt mark fish well. 2d sonar marks fish better but structure is harder to make out. Then i found the humminbird 346c DI and to me this looks to be the best of both worlds, looks like i can have either or in the same unit? So thats where i am at, any hints, suggestions, tips are very welcomed!
 

fishrdan

Admiral
Joined
Jan 25, 2008
Messages
6,989
Re: which model fishfinder?! help!

I need a new fishfinder. I thought this would be easy, NOT!

LOL, you're not alone!!!

I went through the same thing and for me it boiled down to a Humminbird 581 HD DI as I didn't see the need for a color screen, but wanted the option to get good GPS maps in the future (for an extra $150... :rolleyes:) I actually swapped out all my electronics and bought a Humminbird 570 DI too. The option of going full screen 2D, full screen DI or split screen 2D/DI sold me on the Humminbirds. I hope it was a good choice as I was a long time Lowrance/Eagle user and jumped ship, have them installed but haven't used them on the water yet...

One thing I would suggest is a bigger screen than the 346, unless you are always close to it. I have that size on my jon boat which works OK, but I'm always sitting and the FF is on the seat 3' away. I wouldn't like the small screen on my other boat when I'm standing most of the time.
 

870 Expressmag

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 7, 2011
Messages
154
Re: which model fishfinder?! help!

well as far as size, i can get away with a smaller screen due to the fact that my finder is mounted right on the rear bench which is wear i drive and fish from. However after checking out the 581 HD DI like you mentioned, i love the flexibility of being able to use both 2d or DI in the same unit. Only reason i was opting for color was because i was told that differentiating things on sonar was easier with color. Anyone else have any experience with this or a similar model, or any reasons TO or NOT TO go this route? started looking at lowrances but now i may be leaning towards this humminbird
 
Top