Re: 1973 25hp evinrude
Prop and gear selection is controlled by 3 or 4 different components. Starting with the shift rod connector, about 1/2 way down the starboard side of the exhaust housing under an inspection plate. That connector connects upper and lower shift shaft. Look for two bolt heads. Move shifter in and out of gear and make sure both shafts are moving togeather. Lower shift shaft goes to a shift lever in lower unit that moves a shift dog to select gears. Look and make sure there is a phillips head screw in the bottom housing on starboard side, screw holds shift lever in place. There is a shear pin that goes through prop hub and prop shaft. Remove cotter pin and black prop nut behind propeller to expose shear pin, should be in one piece. While you are at prop, see if there are any little pieces of rubber sticking out between prop hub and shaft,indicating a bad prop hub bushing.