I have a 24' with a 90hp. The four blade was best fit for mine. Before it would "spin out" at times in a turn and other problems. The extra surface area seems to have fixed the problems I was having. Cup will help with the "Bite as well".
How is the old prop performing now and how did it perform when newer?
What is your reason for wanting a new prop?
What RPM are you turning at full throttle?
The answers to these questions could make lots of difference.
I would like to no what size prop you are running. I have 24ft tritoon with 90 4stroke merc. Purchased used in January finally had it on the water and it felt like prop ran out at half throttle 4000 to 5000 rpm. It has on it a 13.25 13 pitch. 3 blade