Re: 1972 johnson 6hp impeller replacement
Well I may be speaking out of turn here & not trying to step on anyone's toes, but replacing an impeller just for the sake of doing so in my mind is not justified.
If it is a new motor to you, yes it is a good idea to replace one, but in reference to the one we are discussing here if the impeller looked good AND was still pliable with no cracks, I see no real reason to replace it for a motor of this size/usage.
HOWEVER if this was on a larger ocean fishing motor where you will be offshore many miles & if it (the impeller) went out where you would be paddling until your arms fell off AND put your/your passengers in possible danger, then that is a whole different story.
I just went thru the same thing last week on a 1984 6hp which was new to me. I ordered a new impeller, tore the lower unit off & found my existing impeller was .150" thicker than the new replacement. This motor had sat for 5 years after the previous owner had a bad back injury & became paralized. Upon inspecting the old impeller (which obviously had not been used much) I reused it & feel confident it will function for me many years.