I recently got a 1976 Mercury 9.8 that had not been used in the past few years. I changed the impeller and it ran okay with the exception of a metallic rattling sound somewhere on top. I was cruising along with it pumping water for 30 minutes on a lake and at WOT it stopped abruptly. I checked the rope and it was stuck. I removed the cover and the engine wasn't hot to the touch. I had proper fuel/oil with some carb cleaner added. The prop spins fine in neutral, but can't use it to turn over motor in gear. What should I look at first?