Re: 3/4 in. spindel?
3/4 inch spindles on a pontoon trailer is definitely wrong as the load capacity is way short of requirements - tandem axle or not. That axle is barely capable of supporting the trailer alone much less with a pontoon on it. If you are measuring the threads that's the wrong place to measure. Measure the spindle where the outer bearing sits. My guess is you have a 1-inch spindle which is still marginal. If it is 1-1/16 where the front & rear bearing sits that's still only a 2000 - 2200# trailer. 1-1/16 outer and 1-3/8 inner is highly recommended.