Re: 4.3 and 5.7 y pipe... are they the same size?
Check the hole locations where it joins to the sternplate. You need to know what you have. Some have 4 holes in an equally spaced pattern, some have 4 holes in an offset pattern. My '87 Searay with twin 350's and Alpha outdrives had one of each from the factory .....
3 of the holes are in the same location, the 4th one won't line up if it's the wrong Y-tube and you'll have to hope some silicon will keep it from leaking on you. You'll be MUCH better off getting the correct one unless you want to pull the engine again later to stop the leak ....
Y-pipe with symmetrical mounting holes:
Sternplate with offset mounting hole: