GOOD NEWS. . . . The PICTURE UPLOAD FUNCTION IS WORKING !!! The tech folks at the parent company have been able to remedy the issue. You can upload pictures once again. Thank you for your patience.
I am looking at a couple new pontoons and have two priced to me. One has a 2005 50 HP Merc 4 stroke ( bigfoot) and the other a 2004 50hp Merc 2 stroke. Boats are about the same with $1800 more for the 4 stroke. Worth it?
ive got a 21ft tracker party barge with a 1998 merc 40 hp 2stroke, and i hate it. the motor is very loud and there is a LOT of vibration, man i wish i had got a 4 stroke,dont make the mistake i did----- get the 4 stroke!
That 50hp 2 stroke is a carbed model, right? The only reason I'd buy the 4 stroke is for fuel economy. Pontoon boats are relatively slow and take more time "getting there". Fuel costs start to add up if you do much boating. I have a 20' toon with 50hp 4 stroke and would go with a 2 stroke eTec if buying new now. <br /><br />About resale and for whatever it's worth...last year I checked my 4 stroke against the comparable year and size 2 stroke for NADA value. The 2 stroke had a higher book value...and my 4 stroke was orginally the same price as a 75hp 2 stroke. It was also way more to purchase than a 50hp 2 stroke back then. The 4 stroke lost a higher % of the purchase price than the 2 stroke. It may be different with bigger 4 strokes but most people buying small motors (50 & under)still like 2 strokes. People can debate the NADA prices but 95% of the dealers and lending institutions I deal with pull the NADA book out when talking money. It is used more often than not. <br /><br />I'm guessing in CA the demand for 4 strokes is higher because 2 strokes have been outlawed...that may be something to consider about resale or purchase too.
Retro:<br /><br />I just traded a 50 Merc carbed 2 stroke. It was almost brand new but I just could not stand it any more. GET THE 4 STROKE! Merc makes some good motors but this is not one of them. The only way I'd ever recommend one is if someone were pressed for money and needed a fast engine to run full throttle from point a to point b. The're okay for that.<br /><br />Take Locknut's advice and get the four stroke. Good luck with your new outfit. Bill
I replaced a 1990 40hp Yam (2cyl) 2 stroke with a new 40hp Yam (3cyl & carbs ) 4 stroke. The old engine is the one that came on the boat from new. I wish I had done it years ago. The boat is transformed. It's like having a new boat. It's so quiet and smooth. A real pleasure to use. I'm delighted with it. At full throttle I can hold a normal conversation with people. This was'nt possible with the 2-stroke. <br /><br />I'd definitely recommend a 4 stroke.
Reality check here. In case it matters, noise and smoke are almost a non issue with most pontoon boats. The motors are buried behind furniture and down far away from people. Even with carbed 2 strokes you don't hear or smell them like regular boats. My neighbor has a toon with carbed 2 stroke and the difference is nil compared to my toon with a 4 stroke. We both share motor access problems and working on them while hanging in a boatlift is a bixch. Mine has to be trailered out to service valves and make oil changes easy. Even checking crankcase oil is a bixch.<br /><br />
