4 strokes versus 2 strokes

P.V.

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Mar 14, 2002
Messages
452
Re: 4 strokes versus 2 strokes

I'll agree with you, four strokes cost more than a 2 stroke! No doubt about it, that's why people still buy a 2 cycle. Cost savings. My business is on a medium size lake. I'm am often ask'd by a potential cusyomer if he thinks he should buy a four stroke. It does weigh more, costs more and if he only goes around the bend approx. 1 mile or so and then uses his electic bow mount motor, why go to the extra expense?? He may be right. He just may not get the benifit that others who travel further, troll all day long...yada. yada.. No harm. However, this is the example I use frequently if someone truely wants to justify "the expense" of an "expensive four stroke". I'm not at work and don't have my price sheets nor my business calculator so please give me some slack on this! But here's the example I'll use. (and the difference on the newer high horsepower motors is larger) but let's use a 115 hp 4-stroke as an example. Let's say the the 115 four stroke retails for $7800 and the 115 two stroke retails for ... hum... $6400. We have a difference of $1400. First of all, buy the motor you can afford but consider this.. On a new $21,000 boat, motor, trailer package financ'd over 10 to 12 years, the monthly payment difference PER MONTH (that's out of your pocket each month) is only about 6 or 8 dollars. Or so! Again, don't beat me up on this, I don't have the exact numbers in my head but it's not too far off!! So, the question really is... Is the four stroke worth it ,to you, an extra 8 dollars a month, in fuel savings ( each time you use it) reliability, peace of mind, fill in the blanks.........over a two stroke motor??? I would caution you to save your answer 'till you ride in one. And certinally ask you fellow fishermen at the dock who are running one what they think... <br />Now as to those twin 225 four strokes on the back of offshore canyon runners and the additional costs involved, the dollar difference is bigger but these people don't want to be stuck 40 miles offshore and rely on a motor they just don't feel confident with. If you don't trust your boat to bring you and your family back... why would you go ????? What cost do you put on that?? Anyway, I just get a little peev'd when I still here from people who say four strokes are "pigs", too heavy, too slow, too much maintance, Other than a bass boat, they are fine, fine machines and for the most part, misunderstood by only those people who have never run one OR try to do an apple to apple comparsion against a two stroke!!
 

boating brad

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 7, 2003
Messages
201
Re: 4 strokes versus 2 strokes

i read an article about this topic at iboats used re-manufactured (for sale) outboard motors, dont know if its still there, it has been several months ago. basically they did tests on two stokes and four strokes (mercury), the new two strokes outperformed the four strokes in almost every catagory, the two strokes even match the four strokes in emissions. check it out for yourself, it is very interesting.
 

boating brad

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 7, 2003
Messages
201
Re: 4 strokes versus 2 strokes

i just looked for the same information but its not there anymore, but there is some info, just not the test results that were there before. maybe sombody else knows what i am talking about. :)
 

PAkev

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Sep 9, 2002
Messages
665
Re: 4 strokes versus 2 strokes

I had the opportunity to test ride a 19ft Trophy powered by a 115 Mercury 4 stroke right after iceout this spring and am convinced a 4 banger will be hanging off the back of my new boat. Both quiet and responsive with adequate power in the hole and on a plane. This is a nice motor but I am waiting to see what is being offered in the new 150 HP 4 stroke which Yamaha will be unleashing in the hopefully near future.<br /><br />As far as 4 stroke technology I don't believe there is a cookie cutter answer because as they say "DIFFERENT STROKES FOR DIFFERENT FOLKS"<br /><br />Tournament guys who need to get from point A to point B quick will demand high RPM's found in 2 strokes. However, while I am at work and the wife and/or kids want to take the boat out, they have one less thing to worry about by not having to check or add oil. I'm in no race and want the least amount of bothers so that I can enjoy my boating. It's not how everyone sees it, but this is what works for me.<br /><br />Kevin
 
Top