Thanks guys, I pulled one of them to compare and aside from the gap being less the BPR6EFS were identical in size to the AC's that were in it. I went ahead and gapped them to .045 (noted in the manual and on the top cover) and replaced all 16. The motors fired right up and idled much smoother.
A side note, I found 3 plugs that were barely finger tight. The dealer we purchased from last year had both motors out pre-purchase for transom assemblies, so I stupidly assumed they would have checked everything. Maybe they loosened themselves sometime last season. . I had always noticed the port motor didn't pull as many revs as the stbd on hole shot, maybe that was our cause. The cap and rotors were in bad shape as well.