Re: '87 Evinrude 4hp OB - cleaned carb but still won't start
Three things required to run: spark, compression and fuel. You have spark. Have you done a compression test? You should be 80 psi or higher. Ideally, the cylinders should be within 10 percent of each other.
With the carburetor rebuild, did you clean out the low speed jets with a piece of wire accessing them through the main venturi inside of the throttle butterfly plate? If you didnt replace the welch plug, you didn't clean them from the top. The other way to clean them is to remove the welch plug and clear the jets from the top, then replace the welch plug.
Did you replace the main jet or re-use the old one? When looking through the jet with light behind it, a clogged jet could still "look" alright by nature of a round hole, but that hole can be clogged uniformly with old gas crud. You need to be sure the round hole is the right diameter. I have seen jets that "look" good, but when a jet cleaning tool or wire is run through, the old gas crusty stuff comes right out and the diameter gets a lot bigger. The result is "holy cow, that was really blocked!"
A new grommet will be fuel resistant plastic. If the flat o-ring and grommet are not air tight, the carb will leak air messing up the proper combustion mix. Even with good compression and spark you may not get a good robust explosion in the cylinder.
There's two paths fuel can take in the carb, the low speed path or the high speed path. This is why I try to separate high speed running from low speed running. If the engine won't start at high speed, you have something blocking fuel through the high speed section of the carb and you'll probably have no chance of starting at low speed. If it runs at high speed and won't at low, then you have a blockage in the low speed section of the carb.
If you are sure the carb is clean all around, then you may have to go deeper into the intake manifold looking for blockage or stuck reed valves.
What is the history of this engine with you? Has it ever run for you or is it a new acquisition?
Dumber question: is the tank vent open?
Good luck.
J