I'm not positive yet that I'll be keeping the motor, because I haven't run it on the boat yet to see the speed I can get from it. It's hard to get an answer of what size is going to give you what speed because bowfishing boats vary so much. Most people are running old aluminum boats from a lot of different manufacturers so there are so many weight variables, from the hull itself to the generators, from the little super light weight Honda eu2000 on up to my champion 4500 or bigger, and lights, some run LEDs that weigh next to nothing, some of us run high pressure sodium parking lot lights that weigh around 30 pounds each (I have 3 and need atleast 1 more). Then there's the shooting decks, some use 2x4s and plywood, some use all aluminum, some flush with the gunwales, some a foot or two above them. Then you still have to factor in the fish, which is going to be over 200 lbs on a decent night. I'm my research I've found people with roughly my size boat happy with 4s and I've found people with 9.9s talking about moving to 15s. I will definitely keep this thread updated whatever route I end up going though.