I have been told I should put a smaller prop on my boat wich is a 23 foot campion cruiser fiberglass. It has a 19 on it now. I am putting in a new 302 and want to match prop. It was suggested a 16 or 17. Any input would help
Were you able to run it with old engine and see what the performance was?
Was it getting the engine to recommended WOT rpm range?
Without a basis point of what RPM range at WOT its hard to say, as long as the 19" is in good shape I would trial that then make an educated decision.
Depending on what gear ratio is in the drive I would think somewhere between a 17- 19" is where you would land, 15 or 16" if you have a lower gear ratio or go with a 4 blade.