When I bought my boat it had a smaller battery in it & looked old, so I went to wal mart & got a new dual purpose battery. I never got around to taking to old one back in for the core exchange & it's been sitting on a block of wood in the garage. The new one was perfect all last summer, I was out on the water a few times every week & it never gave me a problem. I hooked up a battery charger/maintainer once or twice over the winter to keep it charged up in the garage. This past Saturday I put the new battery back into the boat & slapped the charger/maintainer it's been several days now & it doesn't seem to want to charge back up, the charger/maintainer reads charging (yellow light) but won't go to the charged (green) light. I pulled the battery & put the charger/maintainer on the old one to check to see if it was the charger or the battery not functioning. The old battery went to fully charged (green light) in about 2 hours, but the new one won't. What could have happened to this battery? Do I return it? Just buy a new one? Or, put it on a "real" battery charger & see what happens? Could this battery be shot already? Just confused.