While your current prop looks in decent condition, it is the stock round eared design and aluminium. Not meant to go-fast. Test a couple of high performance stainless props (if you can ) and buy the best. Of course, with trim all the way in, the bow is down and you are plowing water with a lot of wetted hull area. You definitely need to get the trim up and the hull to ride looser.
I personally like the Ballistic design stainless. It has more blade area and is fully cupped. It has less slip so you get more speed for your RPM. A 21 pitch would probably be close to what you need.