Crestliner vs Lund

vmaxed

Cadet
Joined
May 4, 2002
Messages
16
Looking to buy a new fish/sport aluminum boat... any good advice between these two. I live in Maine, and fish a vast variety of lakes. I've narrowed out Tracker from looking at them closer (cheaper qualities), Lund seems to be a very good quality boat, but very expensive. Crestliner looks to be the best of both worlds. ?????
 

rickdb1boat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jan 23, 2002
Messages
11,195
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

My Brother-in-Law has had a 17' Crestliner fish and ski, with a 48spl Johnson, for 3 years now and it is a very good boat. Well built and has a good ride in fairly rough water. Never had a problem with it, although he is a real stickler for Maintenence and Clean-up, as we all "Should?" be! From what I have seen and riden in, it would be my choice, if I were to want that type of boat!
 

Valv

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 12, 2001
Messages
391
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

I buy liquidation from dealers and last year I had 2 shipment of Crestliner and Lund boats parts, this showed me how well they are built.<br />Even if they belong to same company (Genmar) I liked Lund parts more than Crestliner. I think thay are made with better materials, and they do carry a high name here in MN.<br />It's a tough choice, but I'd go Lund.
 

steelespike

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Apr 26, 2002
Messages
19,069
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

I know nothing about current Crestliners.<br /> Bought my 77 Barebones 18 ft utility new.<br /> Ill be first to admit that it has always been ridden hard at put away wet but also never impressed me with its toughness. Had to rebuild transom after only about 6 years.Seats were<br />cheap plywood with ceaper covering that was<br />completely shot after only about 5 years.<br />Replaced seats at about 7 years.Havent had to touch either seats or transom since then.Screws tended to come loose on seats Plagued by minor rivet leaks since<br /> the early 80s.
 

JS2

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Mar 20, 2002
Messages
43
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

Lunds have a premium pricetag but still use plywood for the seats.
 

plywoody

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Messages
685
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

I have a Crestliner 17 and it has been a pretty good boat all in all. Had to replace the floorboards and the carpeting, but other than that, it has been ok.<br /><br />Far and away, by leaps and bounds, the best small 16' aluminum boat I have ever been around, and the best riding small boat I have ever had was a Duroboat, made in Edmonds, Wa. I sold the thing, and wished I had kept it now. Sadly, I was unemployed at the time, and my banker, spoilsport that he was, thought it better that I sold it, rather than just skip the payments.<br /><br />www.duroboat.com<br /><br />Not sure if they have a dealer anywhere near there, and they are a little more money, but they have no welds or rivets at all, and are put together with a patented lifetime guaranteed seal. It will take a pounding without hardly feeling it, and sure felt solid.<br /><br />I had a 15 ft deep V, with a 40 hp Johnson. A perfect rig! When I finally get rich again, I'm going to trade in my 17 Crestliner I bought used for a new 16 footer!
 

Boatist

Rear Admiral
Joined
Apr 22, 2002
Messages
4,552
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

I have a 1980 21 Foot Crestliner that I bought new. I use boat 50 percest freshwater and 50 percent saltwater. I keep it on the trailer and covered when not in use. Boat came with a 20 year hull warranty. To this day does not leak a drop, have not replace any parts that came with the boat except the horn two year ago. On my boat all the screw and bolts are stainless steel but the nuts on the back side are galivanized and some have rusted. I do not like the current line of Crestliners as well as older ones but still fine boats. Mine is a closed bow runabout but also have two friends that have the open bow Fish and Ski models. Both of them love there boats also.<br />Thing to know about aluminum boats is they are lighter to trailer and lighter on the water so need less HP. Also since they are lighter have a tendency to go more over waves than thru, so can ride a little ruffer. My boat is good in seas up to 8 feet every 8 sec. Been out a few times in 9 feet every 7 sec but very ruff in my boat and had to slow way down. At this point stay in port if over 8 feet and do something else. Buying an aluminum boat I would look for two things, check the bottom for dents or bows. Also note how many rivets it has. I perfer all welled and no rivets because my other aluminum boat has lots of rivets and lots of leaks from loose rivets. If boat you alr looking at has dents or bows I would not buy it as it will affect the performance and also tell you how hard boat was run. If you are looking for a smooth ride in aluminum get one with a deeper V hull. I know nothing about Lund but will not be afraid to buy any Creastliner well cared for. I love my boat and check for larger ones every year. Later model Creastliner have had less storage for: Anchore, flare gun, life jackets, tools boxes, fishing poples, boat hooks, fenders, roapes, Gafs, sea anchore, ect.
 

FISH'N101

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Nov 26, 2001
Messages
39
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

I have a 2000, 1650 Fish Hawk SC with a 90 hp Johnson , 9.9 Mercury kicker, & Minn Kota 50lb thrust elec. troll on the front. This is my third season with the boat. I do try and take good care of mine. Fish & boat hard but good maintance & a dry carport. <br />I originally looked at Lund, Smoker Craft, Trackers, Alumaweld to name a few. Alumawelds were great but a little out of my price range. Lund, Smoker Craft in our (Seattle Washington) area are all very similar. The Crestliner features a No Rivet construction and a fantastic warranty on hull and flooring. If you compare specifications and price the Crestliner fairs very well, if they have a floor plan that works for you. Their Hull warranty is outstanding. A big key should be the dealer you buy from. Regardless of the brand you buy the dealer is a huge key in your long term satisfaction.<br /><br />I have talked to several Crestliner owners all are very happy with their purchase. <br /><br />I use mine on Larger Lakes and rivers with Big Boat traffic and really does well. Fish for Bass, Trout, and Salmon. The fish Hawk is a very versatile floor plan. I also occasionally take the kids skiing and tubing with no problems. Top speed on mine is 45-50 depending on conditions. I have a bunk style E-Z load trailer allowing me to drive the boat right on the trailer. Loading & unloading are as simple as it can get. <br />I think most of the top brand boats & motors will serve you well if you maintain them properly. Be sure your dealer stands behind whatever you buy.<br /><br />Good Luck!
 

eric fairbanks

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Apr 23, 2002
Messages
34
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

Here is my 2 cents. I recently was in the market for a new aluminum walleye boat--until I found a used Ranger Fisherman in perfect shape way less than a new Alum. boat. Anyways, as far a alum. I have owned tracker, sea nymph, and lund. By far the lund was the best one--the tracker and sea nymph were way to light and I actually spit the sea nymph right down the keel--twice. I would look a Alumacraft--they build a real solid rivited boat--right on par with lund (maybe better) for alot less $. Also, I would look to see who uses wood in their boats. Ranger makes a welded alum. boat--no wood--and cheaper than lund. Starcraft, also in certain models offers a wood free transom. Welded boats crack, rivets leak, and wood rots. My lund 17.5 Tyee was re-riveted once--still leaked which lead to the transom wood rotting. That is why I bought a Ranger, no wood, no rivets, no welds.
 

dpski

Cadet
Joined
Sep 2, 2002
Messages
12
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

I can strongly recommend the Crestliner. I have a 1995 Crestliner Phantom SST 1860. I've taken it through some pretty nasty stuff and it just keeps on going. No problems. I'm in the process of moving up to a bigger boat so this boat is for sale. And no this is not a sales pitch. It's my understanding that this thread originated with the quest for a new boat.
 

sundancer

Cadet
Joined
Sep 11, 2002
Messages
9
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

A friend of Mine just bought a Brand NEW Lund. $24,000 for a fishing boat is a little MUCH. But this Boat is Loaded. The wide body of this boat is Like a much larger Boat & the Gun wale is about 8 in. wide. Large enough to sit on. This Boat has all the Bells & Whistles on it. So you don't have to spend $200.00 here $200.00 there, to equipt it with all the Toys. The New Yamaha 116 HP , 4 cycle outboard, kicks this baby up around 50 MPH. Thats moveing in a 16 ft. Aluminum Boat. Nor a bad Buy. Toys are not only for children.
 

93evinrude

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 9, 2002
Messages
154
Re: Crestliner vs Lund

This is not one of your choices but may be worth a look.The new technology being used by Tracker received a good review in Bass & Walleye Boats this month.It is made of formed aluminum and has no rivets which eliminates alot of the problems associated with aluminum boats and looks just like fiberglass.Unfortunately there is only one model available at this time,I think.
 
Top