Cursed or what?

tlombard

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 26, 2007
Messages
115
Tell me if you think this boat is cursed or if you have had a worse experience with a boat.

I?m not even getting into our experiences trying to find boats before this one. One guy even tried to get us to give him cash and take the number of his friend who supposedly had the titles to the boat and trailer.

A friend bought an 89 Conquest last June. He got what we thought was a really good price on it and everything looked good. He bought it off of Ebay on a Tuesday. Since neither of us owned a truck he had to buy a truck so he could even pick up the boat. He bought a pickup on Thursday evening and on Friday morning/afternoon he took it to my dad?s shop to check it out and fix a couple of small things before picking up the boat. Two miles after picking up the boat the truck died on the side of the highway. He called my dad who came out in his truck and after awhile they couldn?t get it started so they unhooked the boat and took it back to the shop with my dad?s truck. I got there about the time they were leaving with a flatbed trailer to pick up the truck and bring it back. Since it seemed like a fuel pump/filter problem I went to the auto parts store to pick up the parts while they got the truck. Well when they got near the truck they noticed that the highway was shut down to one lane and there were fire trucks and police cars all around. His truck caught on fire while they were gone and burned to the ground. There was literally not one useable part on the truck. Of course the kind police officer still felt the need to give him a ticket for not having proof of insurance (in the truck) and one for not having it registered. Even the title and bill of sale were in the truck so he couldn?t even prove he just bought it. I really wish we had pictures of the truck but the police had it towed and nobody had a camera with them or a camera phone even. He eventually got out of both tickets and his insurance company paid for the truck. It would have been nice had that been the end of the problems.

For tow vehicle #2 he purchased a Jeep Cherokee a week or so later. We took the boat out for the 4th of July on the Mississippi River and everything was great? except that we felt we were risking our lives every time we had to hit the brakes. The Cherokee just didn?t have enough to stop an 18? ski boat which doesn?t seem right. No worries though, he put the Jeep up for sale and someone agreed to buy it. He agreed to replace the serpentine belt before the guy picked it up and went to Autozone to buy the right socket to make the swap. He asked the guy at Autozone if he had something to cut the packaging with so he could make sure it fit right before leaving in case he had to take it back. Without any warning the worker whipped out a pocket knife and no only cut the packaging but cut my friend?s finger requiring a trip to the hospital and stitches. Autozon agreed to pay his deductibles at least but still haven?t paid nearly a year later. Guess that is what he gets for not suing.

Finally he bought another truck after selling the Cherokee and everything seems to be OK with that one other than the fact that it needed a water pump almost immediately and at one point is seemed to want to die at stop signs. We think an idle air controller and idle adjustments have that solved however. The boat made it out one more time and everything was fine. We thought the problems were over? but they were just beginning.

The middle of July we finalized our purchase of a lot on a private lake in Missouri and took his boat on the water to celebrate. It was the perfect day until all of a sudden we started hearing some unpleasant noises on the way back to the ramp to pull it out for the day. He found a guy on Craigslist who worked on boats part time in his retirement and paid him $150 to tell us that the lower unit was fine and that the problem was with the motor. Trusting him, we took the boat back to my dad?s shop and pulled the motor. After putting it on an engine stand we still couldn?t find anything wrong but considering the tolerances are so tight with bearings and such that didn?t tip us off that the motor might not be the problem. I found a motor on Craigslist from a boat that someone was parting out and he was able to hear the motor run before pulling it from the boat. Not a bad deal for less than $200. So this motor went back into the boat? but during the test drive it was clear that the same problem existed. Unfortunately the noise is only present when the motor is under load so we had to make a trip back to the river to find this out. In addition, the shift cable needed adjusting and it was an adventure to even get it into drive.

Since we were back to square one and it was still the fall we decided to just have the boat winterized and deal with it again this spring. After researching forums and talking to people we figured that it was likely the gimbal bearing and/or u-joints and found a mechanic with an actual shop to check them out and fix them. Those were the problems and we also had him try to adjust the shift cable? of course I have to mention that we blew a trailer tire on the way to the shop so there was the purchase of two new tires as well.

We picked up the boat last week and decided when the weather was nice enough one day? it was time for another test ride. We ventured back to the river and down the ramp. The engine fired up as soon as the key was turned with no throttle being applied. We were happy. It went right into reverse and I backed the boat off the trailer thinking everything was golden. Of course it wasn?t. As soon as I tried to go forward I realized we still had issues. The shift cable wasn?t anywhere near right and it was an adventure getting to the dock to wait for my friend. We ended up having not just the shift cable problem hurting us but also the throttle is sticking slightly and it is overheating horribly. We never actually made it out of the marina. Instead we ended up 50 yards down from the ramp tied to the back of someone?s slip while we waited for the engine to cool and rigged up a device to pull back the throttle in a hurry on the way back when it stuck (not even a question of if). We did also make some adjustments to the shift cable which did help and we are close to having it right. After finally getting back to the ramp we got the boat out of the water and back to the ship which had done the last repairs since it was so close. This is where I should also mention that the people at the marina were very kind and actually gave us the ramping fee back because they could tell we were having trouble and didn?t even get out on the water really. They didn?t have to do that but if we make it back to the river I know we?ll be using their ramp again and recommending them to others.

We are also very thankful to Mark (the mechanic) since he walked out there when we showed up and actually found the problem for us free of charge and told us that we could fix it ourselves and save some money. The impeller is completely shot so we are going to replace the whole assembly, housing and all as soon as the parts arrive. Hopefully once we lube up the throttle cable, replace the spring, ajust the shift cable and get the impeller put back together we will be good to go for the rest of the year? although the current string of events would not indicate that we even stand a chance! The boat has officially been on more test runs to see if it has been fixed than actual pleasure outings and it has been almost a year now. I just really hope these are the last of the troubles because I feel kind of guilty for putting the boat idea into his head. We were looking to split one for awhile and then I decided to go ahead and buy a pontoon which he did not want any part of. After one time on the river he decided he had to buy a ski boat and that next week is when the problems started. I really feel guilty since I paid a third of what he did for my pontoon and haven?t had a single problem to date (knock on wood). If the boat sunk tomorrow I would still have gotten my money?s worth out of it!!!

Sound like he is cursed or what?
 

ml8163

Seaman
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
71
Re: Cursed or what?

Have you ever seen the movie Gone Fishin'? I hate that you've had so many problems, but it does sound like the next National Lampoon's... Hope you get everything worked out. :D
 

Deltarat

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Feb 5, 2008
Messages
36
Re: Cursed or what?

Why would you consider buying a boat without having a tow vechile first? It sounds to me that you need to do your homework before getting involved in compulsive buying. Why not just use your Dad vechile from the start. Something that you know is reliable. And to buy another vechile that won't stop properly!!!! Are you nuts? The troubles you had are you own fault. Ever heard of lake testing before purchasing someone else's headache. Doesn't sound like you got a good deal at all. I would stongly rcommend that you invest in more time researching something before "jumping into the fire feet first." Good luck.
 

Marcq

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jul 30, 2007
Messages
241
Re: Cursed or what?

Why would you consider buying a boat without having a tow vechile first? It sounds to me that you need to do your homework before getting involved in compulsive buying. Why not just use your Dad vechile from the start. Something that you know is reliable. And to buy another vechile that won't stop properly!!!! Are you nuts? The troubles you had are you own fault. Ever heard of lake testing before purchasing someone else's headache. Doesn't sound like you got a good deal at all. I would stongly rcommend that you invest in more time researching something before "jumping into the fire feet first." Good luck.

Hey, be easy on him, he just had a boating attack :) , I'm sure they have learned alot

Marc..
 

tlombard

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 26, 2007
Messages
115
Re: Cursed or what?

Someone is a little grumpy. :)

I just posted this to maybe give somebody a little entertainment at our adventure. In no way am I blaming anyone else or saying that we haven't made mistakes because we have.

Regarding the tow vehicle, I can borrow my dad's truck whenever I want but that doesn't do my friend any good. I fully agree that it doesn't make sense to buy a tow vehicle that can't safely stop the boat which is why the Cherokee was sold after pulling the boat one time. Unfortunately you can't alwas test drive a vehicle with the boat behind it. When not towing something the breaks seemed very strong and a Jeep Cherokee should be perfectly capable of hauling this boat but even after redoing the brakes something clearly wasn't right and the decision was made to sell. All in all, the risk was pretty low and he only had the thing a week... and was able to sell it for a little more than he paid for it. Not everyone can afford to run out and buy a brand new boat and truck. Some of us are left searching Craigslist and hoping to find a bargain.

It was an impulse buy and I agree that taking it out on the water would have been a good idea before buying. A lake or river isn't always convenient to where the seller is located. The river is 20 minutes from his house but the person selling the boat was a good hour from being able to get on the water. We had been looking at boats for a couple of months and talking to people to find out what to look for and walked away from plenty. Short of pulling the outdrive off of this boat we would not have found anything wrong. I wasn't involved in the process on this particular boat until after he bought it but I don't fault him on the research. And the first three times we had it on the water everything was perfect so a test run wouldn't have shown any problems to start with. The one mistake I will fully admit to was trusting someone other than a legitimate, full time boat mechanic to check out the lower unit as soon as the problem started. Turns out he did nothing more than charge $150 to look at the oil in the lower unit and then send us on a wild goose chase by telling us it was the motor. The rest of our adventure wouldn't have happened had we taken it to someone good in the first place. The shift cable and throttle problems are a direct result of us switching motors because we believed that the lower unit was indeed fine... which it wasn't. Those are adjustments and a simple spring replacement though. No bid deal when you don't have the overheating issue at the same time. As for the impeller... it happens. They go out and either it works or it doesn't. A water test would have only confirmed that it worked at the time. Will we hook it up to the hose every time before leaving the driveway from now on... you bet your ***** we will.
 

blouderback

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Apr 6, 2006
Messages
304
Re: Cursed or what?

I think you've learned a valuable lesson: You get what you pay for.
 

Lou C

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 10, 2002
Messages
13,055
Re: Cursed or what?

Yep we have all learned those lessons:
a 89 boat new to you, should be checked out by a marine mechanic that you trust, that was what sorted out the issues with my 88 Four Winns, no problems after that
A Jeep Cherokee for a tow vehicle, has the power to tow, but has at least 3 liabilities:
light weight
weak rear springs
marginal brakes
and a 4th in some years, weak cooling system
Anyone towing ANYTHING with a Cherokee or Grand Cherokee needs brakes on the trailer that WORK, for sure
They also need load leveling in the rear, I use Air Lift airbags in my 98 Grand and they work great
And every system needs to be up to par, esp brakes, cooling, trans, and use syn gear oil in the diffs.
 

oops!

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Oct 18, 2007
Messages
12,932
Re: Cursed or what?

kinda sounded like the day from.....with the truck burning and all


one of the first lessons i learned was ....if you dont know about it...pay the money for someone that does.......

the retired boat guy...for a buck fifty was the first mistake.....that one fifty cost you 600....and so on........

but as far as the boat bieing cursed......id say the owner needs to spend some knee time !

:) :) :)
 

tlombard

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 26, 2007
Messages
115
Re: Cursed or what?

There will be plenty of knee time in a week or two when we get out to the lake. Lord knows we were praying the other day on the river when we realized that the shift cable still wasn't right and the current was taking is to a bad place while we were trying to get it into forward. Luckily reverse was fine and we were able to avoid problems. No more river for us. There is too much trouble to be had if something goes wrong. We'll just eat the extra gas money and drive an hour and a half each way to try it out at the lake. Once we get it all right we'll be able to store it down there and not have to haul it both ways. Hopefully my pontoon survived the winter so it doesn't need a trip back to St. Louis. That thing is a beast on the windy rural road in and out of the area.
 

jaxnjil

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 3, 2007
Messages
1,368
Re: Cursed or what?

sound pretty normal to me. excpept the first truck burning up.
sounds like boat must be a ib? if it is sound like you need to quit messing around trying to adjust shift cable and replace it and the bellows when change the pump. i think you said you still have to change the pump? any way you now have a spare motor for not much.
sound like you had more trouble with tow rigs than the boat
 

AguaSki

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 4, 2005
Messages
545
Re: Cursed or what?

I don't think the boat is cursed. Although you have had a run of bad luck, all the problems are fairly typical for a boat that age. Instead of bad luck, you are paying for neglect by the prior owner. It may still take a few more buck'$ to get ahead, and after you get everything running well you will have the continued expense of ongoing maintenance. Hopefully you are now at a point where you can enjoy the boat.
 

Rdraidr

Cadet
Joined
Jul 12, 2006
Messages
23
Re: Cursed or what?

Had one I cursed at...not nearly as bad a string as you guys, but every bloody time we hit the lake, the darn thing would stop running and would not start for crap. Not for throttle open, closed, starter fluid, nothing! Finally, one day I decide to lift the stern drive up and WHAM, started every time - bad compression I decided. On the second boat, having a much better time! Tow vehicle is a GMC Denali XL - not one single problem in 93k miles - probably won't start tomorrow.
 

wca_tim

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
May 28, 2007
Messages
1,708
Re: Cursed or what?

or what!

you nearly escaped a firey death on the side of the road in an old truck,

didn't wind up getting pushed into the path of an oncoming cement mixer in a cherokee,

didn't get shot by an overzealous cop or beaten by one that thought you were impolite (after being properly chastized for leaving a burning, uninsured vehicle in the road,

did not have to swim back from a boat ride in boots in cold spring water, and

apparently had the money to finance your adventures! and you even have a cool story to tell...

Dude, how can you think that's cursed??!?!!!
 

arboldt

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 25, 2007
Messages
417
Re: Cursed or what?

I hope you don't mind my getting a good laugh at your tale of woe. It does sound like quite a ... umm ... learning experience.:rolleyes:

Guys, don't be too hard on him.. Sure he's made mistakes, but haven't we all? We've chided him for not taking it to a trusted mechanic, but if he's new to boating, how would you know who to trust? Most of our boating is at a cottage 150 miles north of our home.

A couple years ago we were having problems with our boat. I may know simple mechanic stuff, but I also knew this was beyond me. The closest mechanics near the cottage are almost 50 miles away, so we decided to take it home to get worked on.

In our city, there are three marinas. One way northeast of town, one way northwest, on one a little south. I had no way of judging if any were good or not. So that September we took it to the one closest to us, about 5 miles south of town. Cost us $1400 to replace most of the ignition electronics. It was an established business -- how could we have known the guy was terrible? The next year the engine began running even worse, and eventually wouldn't even start. So in August we took it to one of the other marinas, and didn't get it back until January -- took it up to the cottage for winter storage in a snowstorm. Not only did they have to fix what the original problem really was, but also fix what the first guy screwed up. Ended up costing almost double what we paid the first time. Only through bitter experience did I learn what mechanics can be trusted or not.
 

dsstephens

Cadet
Joined
Aug 28, 2007
Messages
11
Re: Cursed or what?

tlombard - funny story - thanks for sharing

can't be experienced without actually having experiences. seems folks really forget that sometimes.
 

erikgreen

Captain
Joined
Jan 8, 2007
Messages
3,105
Re: Cursed or what?

I think stories like this are the norm for brand new boat owners... how many of us were really listening to the old salts when we first made our purchase?

We were all optimistic, looking for a great bargain because we weren't dumb enough to pay a lot for a boat, expecting the boat to handle anything without a hitch, expecting to pay for gas and nothing else the first season.

I can look back and laugh a bit now, but there were many times I wanted to cry.

Erik
 
Top