diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

tomatolord

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Oct 1, 2004
Messages
548
Re: diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

The question is not whether it will burn it is a question of viscosity. cooking oil is too thick at room temps to flow easily so you have to heat it up or cut it with something especially in winter months.

There are 2 types of veggy oils out there.

biodiesel - this is veggy oil cut with different chemicals to allow it to be pumped right into your tank and used normally

pure veggy - where you have a seperate tank of veggy oil - you get the oil for free from resturaunts (they have to pay to have it hauled away) and you filter it yourself. but since you dont have the other chemicals you cannot put it directly into your tank you need a seperate tank. but it is free so.

Tomatolord
 

Terry Olson

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 20, 2005
Messages
415
Re: diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

"Free" used cooking oil will become difficult to find if this catches on. I used to be able to get "free" bear hunting bait from restaurants and bakeries (including used cooking oil) until other hunters started asking for the same waste materials - now they sell those materials since there's a demand for them.

Also consider the cost of equipping your vehicle and calculate how many miles you'd have to drive it before your realize your first cost savings. This is the "solar power" trend of the 70s - a neat concept that just isn't practical.

I'd have to find CONSIDERABLE savings before I'd go out to collect used cooking oil for use as vehicle fuel. With years of restaurant experience while in high school and college I can tell you that the grease traps out back are filthy and disgusting. Then you have to filter it yourself? What kind of setup would you need to filter gallons and gallons of used cooking oil and where would you do this? What exactly is your time worth? What a mess, what a hassle, what a waste of time IMHO.

It's interesting from a discussion standpoint and I'm as happy as anyone to see alternative fuel exploration. Until it becomes not just feasible, financially and otherwise, but also advantageous it will remain nothing more than an interesting topic for discussion. The same can be said for hybrids, E85, hydrogen, electric, and the rest of them.
 

whywhyzed

Banned
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
1,871
Re: diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

french fries must taste horrid on the west coast..... here we cook them at about 350F and the due to the special blending of vegetable oils, there is no smoke. The stuff has a rediculously high flash point which is probably why it costs so much here. But then we also put vinegar on our fries....
Take new veggie oil and heat it to 1500F in a diesel's cylinder, and yes it will light. But it will wreck the engine with it's soot and ash content. One of the reasons the "veggers" want used cooking oil more than new stuff.

I watched veg my ride.... wow what a hassle....as tomato pointed out, the viscosity is the issue. Contamination of the used cooking oil is also a big problem... water and solids...lotsa treatment required before use.

You have to start on diesel, then switch to veggie once everything hot, then.... here's the kicker... if you ever shut it off with the veggie in your fuel pump and lines... you could have a big expensive mess on your hands...
you have to switch to diesel and run for 15 minutes before shutting off.

You need 2 fuel tanks, and a lot of expensive work goes into these conversions. I would estimate they were putting around $10,000 into these old VW's and Mercedes to get em veggie friendly. You could never lend your car to anyone that's for sure.
Good video though.
 

ZmOz

Captain
Joined
Aug 13, 2003
Messages
3,949
Re: diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

Terry said:
Also consider the cost of equipping your vehicle and calculate how many miles you'd have to drive it before your realize your first cost savings. This is the "solar power" trend of the 70s - a neat concept that just isn't practical.

You've got your alternative energies confused. Biodiesel and solar/electric power are two VERY different subjects. The cost to "equip" your vehicle can range from nothing to a few hundred bucks depending on the vehicle you have and what kind of fuel you want to burn. It won't take very many miles to recoup the cost, because diesel is nearly $3.50/gallon. If it costs you $500 to convert, you only need to burn 142 gallons before you come out ahead. I can do that in a weekend.

Solar power is completely different - it didn't make financial sense in the 70s and still doesn't today. Biodiesel/WVO does make a whole lot of financial sense.


kjdkjd said:
Take new veggie oil and heat it to 1500F in a diesel's cylinder, and yes it will light. But it will wreck the engine with it's soot and ash content.
No, it won't. There are LOTS of people who run straight vegetable oil in their engines. The only modifications are to the fuel delivery system. The engine still burns it just as well as anything else. Flash point has nothing to do with how completely a fuel burns.

kjdkjd said:
I watched veg my ride.... wow what a hassle....as tomato pointed out, the viscosity is the issue. Contamination of the used cooking oil is also a big problem... water and solids...lotsa treatment required before use.
Again, that depends on what you are burning. With clean veggie oil as the original poster was asking about, none of this is the case. Yes, it's alot of filtering if you get used oil from a restaurant, but you're also saving $3.50 for every gallon you filter. That adds up REAL quick.

kjdkjd said:
You have to start on diesel, then switch to veggie once everything hot, then.... here's the kicker... if you ever shut it off with the veggie in your fuel pump and lines... you could have a big expensive mess on your hands...
you have to switch to diesel and run for 15 minutes before shutting off.
Again, this depends on what kind of fuel system you have setup and what kind of fuel you're burning. Biodiesel does not require this at all. Straight vegetable oil does, but not if it's mixed with diesel fuel. No, you do not have to run your engine for 15 minutes after you switch back to diesel. (rolleyes) You have to run it long enough to clear the oil out of your fuel lines, which doesn't take very long at all. If you forget to do this before your engine gets cold, (not just before you shut off) all you have to do is drain your fuel lines. That's not a "big expensive mess".

kjdkjd said:
I would estimate they were putting around $10,000 into these old VW's and Mercedes to get em veggie friendly.
I think you need to purchase a calculator. No, it doesn't cost anywhere CLOSE to $10,000. You'd have a hard time spending more than a thousand dollars. You could do it almost free depending on the vehicle you start with and the fuel you want to burn. It never costs $10,000 to convert. Ever. I could convert my GAS powered jeep to SVO for around $2500, including the diesel engine!

To the original poster:
If you still want to do this, I strongly suggest you find a biodiesel forum and start asking questions. There are lots of them. Asking this question on a boat forum is like asking how to fix your boat on a biodiesel forum - you won't get very good advice there about boats. Here is a great page that dispels most of the myths being posted here:
http://www.answers.com/topic/straight-vegetable-oil
 

Bob_VT

Moderator & Unofficial iBoats Historian
Staff member
Joined
May 19, 2001
Messages
26,065
Re: diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

TerryOlson - Need bear bait? Find a place making biodiesel and ask them for the solids. We have tons of the solids that are filtered off in the first portion of the process. It is not toxic because nothing has been added.

Throughout the process there are always solids left in various mixes however the first filtration is what you want. If there is a place making it offer to leave a few empty 5 gallon buckets and they will gladly accomodate that..... we would!
 

Terry Olson

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 20, 2005
Messages
415
Re: diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

I'm done with bear hunting - too much work and too little time actually hunting. It always made me nervous to be carting hundreds of pounds of donuts to a hole in the ground where I KNOW bears are coming to feed.
 

whywhyzed

Banned
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
1,871
Re: diesels and veggy oil... just outa curiosity

In the video the guys were spending about 10G's to get it to work on used or new vegetable oil.
 
Top