Floor replace

soak 'n fused

Seaman
Joined
May 31, 2006
Messages
53
I need to replace the floor on a 16' Larson. The old floor is out and I plan on buying A & B foam to re-fill the floor as it has dry rot and a lot of voids. I want to secure my seats to the floor on pedestals but I am in a quandry. I would like to anchor down with maybe 2" x 6" which happens to be the space between my stringers. My question- how do I secure the anchors or hold them in place if I am going to put the floor down first and then pour the foam. Could I put screws horizontally through the stringers to secure them or is there another way. I thought about cutting out the old foam and laying the wood in resin but then I still have old foam. Any thoughts? :confused:
 

JasonJ

Rear Admiral
Joined
Aug 20, 2001
Messages
4,163
Re: Floor replace

If you are just running lags through the floor and into the anchoring wood underneath then yes, you would run screws horizontally through the stringers into the anchor wood. I don't know what you mean when you talk about the foam. You shouldn't have any old foam at all.
 

sport15

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Jun 1, 2006
Messages
95
Re: Floor replace

Get rid of any wood that has dry rot. What/where are the voids? If this is the area between the stringer and the frames there is no harm leaving that open. If your intent is to fill those areas with the A B foam you are going to gain a lot of weight and it isn't going to be cheap. If you are worried about floatation, the blue foam insulation works really well and the sheets are cheap, closed cell (essential) and come in a variety of thickness. The foam is very easily worked with a sure form tool or a bunch of old hacksaw or band saw blades welded together. If you want to install cleats to fasten the seats to, the way you describe is fine, fastening to the stringers, just be sure that you encapsulate the 2x6 in epoxy. When you install the deck you would be better off to over drill the holes for the seats, fill the holes with thickened epoxy and once set up drill and tap for stainless machine screws. This ensures that there is no way for water to get under the deck by the seats.. I assume that you will use plywood for the deck and by drilling for lag screws there is no way to ENSURE that you will not get water intrusion through the lag holes. <br />Good luck!
 

soak 'n fused

Seaman
Joined
May 31, 2006
Messages
53
Re: Floor replace

Thanks for the help Jason J and sport 15- ok now hear me out Jason .... the problem with the hull side of installing the pedestals/seats is that if I pull out all the old foam( which I should do as it is all dry rotted and still leaking a trail of water) there is no stringer on the hull side to suport the 2x6 to. So, how do I support a 2x6 block to support a seat with no foam or stringer to attach to? And Sport 15 thanks much for the idea to fully soak the 2x6 blocks. But maybe instead of overdrilling and drill and tap could I resin the lags or use 5200 on the lags? I dont anticipate much water underneath the seats.
 

510man

Cadet
Joined
Jan 7, 2006
Messages
19
Re: Floor replace

Can you install the seat supports from the underside of the floor before it's installed? <br /><br />1) You'd have to measure carefully to determine where the peds go on the new floor. <br />2) Attach a 2x6 or whatever is suitable to the underside of the floor with construction adhesive ans SS screws.<br />3) Drill your ped bolt holes clear through the plywood and 2x6.<br />4) Install T-nut fastners on the back side of the ped mount you just built.<br />5) Install the floor.<br />6) Your ped would now bolt through the plywood floor and thru the 2x6 reinforcement to the T-nut fastener resulting is a solid bolt through design.<br /><br />It would eventually rot through but would probably take 10+ years. How long will you keep the boat?
 

sport15

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Jun 1, 2006
Messages
95
Re: Floor replace

Moose,<br />I now see a drastic differance of opinion. I am an AVID fan of make it water tight and keep it that way. I have had REALLY bad luck with water intrusion on boat platforms that I have bought in the past and the only way to stop this is to make physical barriers. Slicon on metal leaks after time, water leaks down the bolts to the t nuts and seeps into the sub straight and rot starts. Up north it will freeze over winter and enlarge any void it gets into. So, the real question is how much extra time do you want to spend the first time do make it phsychoticly water tight vs. doing it twice over time. Many years ago I was a fitter in Patti's shipyard and the first thing I learned was there is never enough time to do it right the SECOND time so get it right the first....<br /><br />With the deck removed and easy access to the guts of the hull there are a number of options.<br />To keep things straight: (there may be slight variations to the definitions depending on your location and background) I apologize if this is preaching to the choir..<br /><br />A “stringer” runs for and aft, is normally parallel to the center line, and fastened to the bottom of the inside of the boat.<br />A “floor” in a ship is the steal tank top of a storage tank in the bottom of the hull OR the member that ties two frame ends together across the top of the keel (really common in wooden construction) OR the shallow transverse piece that runs across the keel of a small boat on which the deck lands.<br />A “clamp” is fastened to the side of the boat and is a landing place for a deck or deck beam.<br /><br />If the foam is completely shot, ie crumbles to the touch and is full of water you are right, it should come out. Sorry about that but there you go. See option B. HOWEVER, if it does not crumble and does dry out you have hope. If you cut out a small chunk and put water on top, does it weep through? If yes, than get rip of the foam because that means it is NOT closed cell and in a marine application it is worthless. If water does not permeate the foam and it is tight, this is option “A” and we now have a COMPLETELY different game.<br /><br />Option A.<br /> With the deck removed and the foam faired flat or with a very slight (1/8 inch/foot) crown, with a sharpie pen mark the foam where the pedestals should go. If you are happy with the location, after looking at it a while, whip out the straight edge and square up the markings and line off the shape of the cleats that you are going to use. If you are not positive of the pedestal location make the cleat big enough to cover the area that you think you will use. If it is going to be a 2x6xX heave the cleat into the boat, trace it out and cut out the shape. An easy but insanely messy way to do it is with a router on a wide Plexiglas base with a plunge cutting dado bit set at a depth of 1/8th deeper than the thickness of the cleat. Start at the middle of the marked up foam and work your way out. This makes for a unbelievable amount of NASTY foam dust, keep the shopvac hammering….<br />When all is cleaned up mix up a batch of thickened epoxy, blob it the hole with a home built trowel with 1/8th inch teeth cut in it, smear it all around, add a little for the wife and kids and then drop the cleat in. Make sure there is enough epoxy goop in the cutout to spooge out when the cleat is dropped in. Leave a heavy enought weight on the cleat to keep it from floating out. Repeat for the other side. When you lay the deck, AFTER you have put at least 3 coats of unthickened epoxy on the bottom of the deck, slather the top of the cleats with thickened epoxy set the deck down and weights to hold it down and wait for the cure. If all you have to fasten the deck to is the foam, I learned the hard way the MOST solid way to do this is with a pile of thickened epoxy toweled in, like you would glue tile to the kitchen floor, all over the top of the foam. It takes a lot to do the job but the difference between the “rigid” bond you get this way, and the “semi” rigid bond you get from something like 5200 is huge. I did this to a skiff, I ran out of epoxy during a job and used 5200 for the rest. The epoxy side is solid, no give, just a flat smack when hit. The 5200 has give and rings every so little. I wanted the former….<br />When all this is done, fillet the edges to ensure you have no exposed end grain, cover the fillets with tape, sand fair then glass the deck to the hull sides.<br /><br />Option B. (Grossly simplified)<br /><br /> Build your own stingers and floors, glue, fillet and glass them in place. When laying out the floors, space them so you can fasten the cleats to them, maybe let them into the tops of the floors. As stated before make sure the cleats are encapsulated in epoxy. At the height of the tops of the floors, glass clamps to the sides of the hull. Cover all this with your favorite adhesive and drop the deck on top. <br /><br />Just a few thoughts…
 

soak 'n fused

Seaman
Joined
May 31, 2006
Messages
53
Re: Floor replace

sport 15- you are only a cadet on this forum but you should be an ancient mariner lol thanks much for the advice. Ok I am going to do the seat pedestals like you described..I wasnt going to put three coats on the bottom of the deck but that is a good idea..now for the half inch gap between where the old floor sat and as the result of cutting it out I left about 2 inches from the sides to sit the new floor onto. How can I build this up to my desired height? I can use thickened epoxy,right, but wont that get expensive? Could I build it up with chopped strand mat and layer with cloth mat? I used to dread going out to this boat and staring blankly at the old floor after I cut it out and then thought to myself " what am I doing" Now, each trip I am a little more confident thanks to the help from you and jasonj and 510 man. I gotta get get out there by the 4th of July or my hen is going to kill me!
 

sport15

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Jun 1, 2006
Messages
95
Re: Floor replace

Moose,<br />NEVER underestimate the power of the Big Boss (hen) :D !!!!! <br /><br />I am a little fuzzy on what needs to be done to the deck and what is left behind..<br />I am thinking that you will drop the “new deck” on the two inch lip left behind.<br />This is not bad at all. If the ½ inch is the void that will be created by dropping the deck on the 2 inch lip, skip down to the local Home Depot and get yourself a sheet of that 4x8x1/2 inch blue board and cut and trim to fill the void. Glue that down and drop the deck on top. Then fillet and tape the edges to the hull..<br /><br />What are you thinking about for the deck surface? <br /><br />Why am I partial to epoxy/foam/wood sandwich?<br /><br />I had some leftover epoxy thickened with sanding dust one day and slobbered that on a 2”wide 13” long piece of 2 inch foam blue board and put a piece of 3/16 luan ply on each side. Three days later I tried to break it… I built a jig out of 2x4 and 2/12” sheet rock screws that would hold the piece and a 3 ton hydraulic jack. After pushing the head of the jack through the luan (oops) I flipped it over and tried again with a 2” fender washer under the jack head. I broke the jig... (That was cool!!) I then put it on the floor, bridged on two 2x4’s and pressed this time against the ceiling of the boat shop. I stopped after a resounding crack from a ceiling joist. So, just ‘cause I could I took it outside and ran it over with a 5210 John Deere. It crushed, (duh) but did not break and the glue joint never failed…
 

soak 'n fused

Seaman
Joined
May 31, 2006
Messages
53
Re: Floor replace

Hey sport- your test has me convinced- so then I should put a layer of resin down first, then half inch blue board, then more resin, then the deck? That sounds good but do I need to thicken with sawdust or just resin? Do I need to use a cure? Can I use poly resin or do you swear by epoxy? And what do you mean by fillet and tape the sides to the hull? I appreciate the help - you and others have been huge!
 

sport15

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Jun 1, 2006
Messages
95
Re: Floor replace

Moose,<br /><br />Epoxy seems to have the best adhesion to wood, is non permeable, and if the wood gets damp it does not weaken the epoxy bond. I like that. However, it is at LEAST twice as expensive as vinylester and more than that with polyester resin<br /><br />Polyester resin has built a lot of boats, it has however been found to be permeable, and will not stick to damp wood. It will also eat through polystyrene. I don’t know if the blue board is polystyrene, you could run a little test to see. Just do NOT mix it in a waxed paper cup or a Styrofoam one ‘cause it will eat through. <br /><br />Sorry, I am not really the one to get into the nitty gritty of these and I don’t want to mislead you. Fire up Google/Ask and see what comes up. I somehow ended up on a site that was about fixing Bertram’s and there was some real good stuff there.<br /><br />There is another school of thought on this and that is to use construction adhesive for the foam/foam joint. Again Google and see what you find.. If you can’t tell, I am not waffling, I just don’t want to spend all of you r $$ ‘cause the Epoxy will be expensive. <br /><br />Get the book The Gougeon Brothers on Boat Construction, it is a good reference…<br /><br /><br />Fillet: picture what a weld looks like in a 90 degree joint. Take a tongue depressor or a thin piece of scrap and put a ¼ inch radius on it. When you run in a blob of thickened goop in the deck/hull joint and smooth it out with you home made tool what is left behind is the fillet. If you are using epoxy, after a while the stuff will start cooking and begin to stiffen up. This is called a “green” state and it is the best time to lay fiberglass tape, (go to uscomposites.com and search for tape, they have a picture) on. With the tape on, you then wet the tape out with unthickened epoxy. This saves sanding/washing away the blush that forms on some epoxies after they cure.<br /><br />Thickening agent, your choice. Wood flour is ok, sanding dust the same. They do not cure as smooth as Cabosil or micro balloons but some folks will argue that the former is stronger but it is heavier. Cabosil was cheaper than micro balloons so I bought Cabosil. The goop is mixed so that when you pull the stirrer out the goop stays on the stick. To dry starves the joint of resin to wet just makes a mess. You are shooting for a consistency between, just melted ice cream and Jiff creamy peanut butter.<br /><br />The best way to get the goop in the joint for the fillet is with a "pastry bag". With the epoxy goop I use 6 mil poly home made pastry bags and it works REALLY well. Go to your local bakery and ask them how to fold one up...
 

soak 'n fused

Seaman
Joined
May 31, 2006
Messages
53
Re: Floor replace

Hey sport! MUCH THANKS for your insight! I now have my bearings set for you have given me that much needed boot back out to the garage. You follow up requests graciously. I will keep you up to date with my progress!
 
Top